Concealed Carry

What Size Handgun Should I Carry?

An assortment of pistols on a table

With modern options, there are hundreds of great handguns on the market. This is great because if one doesn’t work for you, ditch it for one that does. But with so many choices, how do you decide which one is right for you?

Most of it is going to be up to personal opinion and how the gun feels to you. Some are going to fit your hand better than others, and you will notice you shoot some better than others. Some will be too big for you to conceal effectively, while others will be too small to handle and shoot well. I’ll attempt to help you narrow it down by examining the pros and cons of different size handguns.

Due to popularity, most of the example pistols I’ll reference are chambered in 9mm, but many are available in other calibers.

three pistols assorted sizes
Some pistols will work better for certain occasions.

Full-Size

The largest handguns are considered “full-size.” These are the typical duty guns you’ll see on a cop’s belt or a soldier’s hip. That’s not to say that these are not for civilians, as these tend to be the easiest handguns to shoot. The heavier weight helps to soak up some of the felt recoil and the longer grip combined with the greater sight radius aids in accuracy and handling. 

The drawback to the full-size handgun is its lack of concealability. The size and weight make it harder to carry concealed all day and it will be more noticeable to other people. However, this does not automatically rule out full-size handguns, as many people are capable of easily carrying a full-size handgun all day long. It mainly depends on your body type, wardrobe, and tolerance.

For me, carrying a full-size pistol isn’t comfortable in most situations. I’m sure other people feel this way, and this makes it more likely that you’ll leave your firearm at home. Having the biggest, baddest carry gun in the world won’t help, if you don’t have it on you when you need it.

There are plenty of great full-size pistols on the market, but I’ll highlight some of the most notable in different styles. The tried and true Government Model 1911 has been serving for over a century and shows no signs of quitting. The crisp, single-action trigger and slim single-stack design make this pistol shoot extremely well and feels great in the hand.

My personal favorite full-size pistol is the SIG Sauer P226. Variations of this pistol have been used by law enforcement agencies, as well as the Navy SEALs, for decades. The P226 has an established track record of incredible durability and legendary reliability. 

One of the most common modern police pistols is the Smith and Wesson M&P full-size. This striker-fired pistol is available in several different calibers and is simple to maintain and is lightweight on the hip with its polymer frame.

long-slide pistols - M&P

Compact

Compact pistols help bridge the gap between handguns that are often too large or too small. Compact pistols feature a slightly shorter barrel and grip than their full-size counterparts. However, they retain many of the features that make them great defensive handguns. This seems to be the sweet spot for most shooters looking for a do-it-all handgun. 

There are some who will think a compact handgun is too large for carry and end up leaving it in the safe or a drawer. In these cases it may as well be a full-size pistol. Although, the smaller grip may feel better in the hand to shooters with smaller hands.

The most popular pistol in this size, and possibly in the United States, is the Glock 19. Due to the popularity of the Glock platform, this pistol will have the most upgrades and accessories available on the market.

Another great option that comes ready to rock right out of the box is the Walther PDP Compact. The Walther PDP incorporates some of the best features that modern shooters are looking for, such as grip texturing, an optics-ready slide, and ambidextrous controls. Finally, I would be remiss if I did not mention the Beretta 92 Compact. The pistol brings all the famed qualities of the military M9 into a more concealable package for everyday carry.

Walther PDP with light
Walther makes several versions of the PDP. This one features the compact slide paired with the full-size frame.

Subcompact

Subcompact pistols are my favorite size for concealed carry. As the name suggests, these are another step down in size. Most subcompact pistols will feature a two-finger grip, with your pinky dangling off. Although, there are pinky extensions for most magazines that will allow for a full grip. 

Due to the reduced size of subcompact pistols, you’ll likely feel a noticeable increase in felt recoil compared to their full-size and compact counterparts. The shorter barrel and sight radius will also cause a decrease in wound ballistics and accuracy at longer ranges. Magazine capacity will also be limited to around 10 rounds depending on the caliber.

<

One of the top subcompact pistols is also a great budget option. The Canik TP9 Elite SC packs a ton of features for a price that won’t break the bank. This is a little larger than most subcompact pistols, but that aids in accuracy and recoil control at the range. 

Another solid subcompact option is the CZ P-10 S. The P-10 S has a higher magazine capacity than most of its competitors with 12-rounds in a flush-fitting mag. The P-10 is also known for having a great trigger and excellent reliability.

The final option here rides the line between this category and the next, but I believe its size fits better in the subcompact zone. The M&P Shield Plus is slimmed down from most subcompacts but still features the same 10-round capacity. The original M&P Shield as well as the newer Shield Plus are some of the top-selling pistols in the country for good reason.

Canik TP9 Elite SC

Micro/Pocket

Stepping down in handgun size again, micro, or pocket, pistols are the most easily concealed. Newer “micro 9s,” as they tend to be referred to, are all the rage right now. These pistols are only slightly larger than traditional pocket pistols but feature a similar magazine capacity to larger subcompact options. This is accomplished by new magazine design and technology that allows you to fit more ammo into a smaller gun. The most popular micro pistols are the SIG Sauer P365 and the Springfield Armory Hellcat. These are reliable and dependable guns that are incredibly popular for concealed carry.

Moving on to more traditional pocket guns, one of the most popular is the Ruger LCP series. My favorite in the bunch is the .380 ACP LCP Max. The Max offers both 10-round and 12-round magazine options and fits nicely in the front pocket of my jeans. This gives you a much higher capacity than any other alternative. A J-Frame revolver is a great option because of the inherent reliability and certain concealed hammer models can be fired from inside the pocket. The Derringer has been a go-to pocket option for decades, although it only provides the shooter with two rounds. Bond Arms makes modern derringers in all sorts of designs and calibers that are extremely well made. Even the budget Roughneck series is a dependable option.

SIG Sauer P365 9mm handgun with a spare magazine left profile
The SIG P365 packs a lot of firepower into a small package.

Carry Methods

If you’re not worried about concealing the firearm, there’s really not much of a reason to not go with a full-size handgun. Openly carried in a strong-side OWB holster, the full-size pistol is fast into action. A full-size pistol is also a great option if you plan on carrying off-body in a bag or vehicle.

Another great option that works well with both full-size and compact options is the shoulder holster. This will require some sort of covering garment, such as a jacket or overshirt, but keeps the weight of the gun off the beltline. There are off-side ammo carrier options to help distribute the weight evenly and provide you with an ample supply of spare magazines.

Inside-the-waistband carry is popular with compact and subcompact handguns. This is probably the most common method of carry, as it provides convenient access to the pistol with good concealability. The main two positions of IWB carry are appendix and behind the hip. Both have their pros and cons, but the main consideration will be how your pistol, holster, and carry position fit with your body type. Those with a bit more of a gut may have a hard time carrying in the appendix position, but for some folks it may offer more concealment.

The easiest and most discreet method of carry is pocket carry. Unfortunately, it requires the shooter to sacrifice draw speed, accessibility, and handgun size. These handguns tend to be chambered in smaller calibers as well. However, you do get a great deep concealment option for when carrying a larger firearm may not be possible.

Ankle carry has similar drawbacks to pocket carry, but draw speed will be hindered even more. However, if you find yourself sitting or driving for most of the day, you may find ankle carry works better for you. 

Blackhawk! IWB Holster
IWB holsters are the most popular for concealed carry.

Final Thoughts

Personally, I lean on the size of a subcompact pistol for everyday carry. I feel it provides me with the best balance between concealability and shootability. However, I also have options in all different size ranges depending on the situation. My carry gun will be very different if I’m going to a wedding or on a camping trip. 

What’s your favorite handgun size for daily carry? Does your choice ever change? Do you have multiple options? Share your answers in the comment section.

About the Author:

Alex Cole

Alex is a relatively young firearms enthusiast who’s been shooting consistently for around seven years. Though he is fairly new to the industry, he loves consuming all information related to guns and is constantly trying to enhance his knowledge, understanding and use of firearms. Not a day goes by where he doesn’t do something firearms-related.

Alex tries to visit the range at least a couple of times a month to maintain and improve his shooting skills. He also enjoys disassembling and reassembling firearms to see how they work and to keep them properly cleaned and maintained. He installs most of the upgrades to his firearms himself, taking it as a chance to learn.

Additionally, he is very into buying, selling and trading guns to test different firearms and learn more about them. He is not only interested in modern handguns and rifles, he appreciates the classics for both historical value and real-world use.
The Mission of Cheaper Than Dirt!'s blog, The Shooter's Log, is to provide information—not opinions—to our customers and the shooting community. We want you, our readers, to be able to make informed decisions. The information provided here does not represent the views of Cheaper Than Dirt!

Comments (13)

  1. Because of my profession I have numerous guns from which to choose and tend to rotate. One that surprised me as to how well it carries and with 13+1 rounds is the Mossberg MC2C. Mossberg deviated from their shotgun rifle production to do this one pistol and they sure got it right. It’s basically the size of the Hellcat Pro with the same capacity, and for some reason the Mossberg feels a little better to me and shoots very well. I’ve been surprised to find other industry professionals that have felt the same way about the MC2C.

  2. I have carried the 1911 colt full size and compact for over 25 years to me they are a perfect fit they feel like an extension me and I shoot them very well

  3. I don’t care what kind of pistol a person uses for self-defense. I just wish authors would stop calling everyone who isn’t a cop a civilian. Cops are civilians too. They aren’t the military and they should not be viewed as a different class of citizenry. For decades people have been making the mistake of thinking law enforcement officials are somehow different from the rest of us. They aren’t. This is a legal fiction which has grown out of the 1967 Pierson v. Ray SCOTUS decision that created the concept of qualified immunity. There has been increasing resentment and resistance to this concept ever since, and one can only hope the idea will eventually be overturned by the high court. Until this happens , please don’t reinforce the delusion by referring to the rest of us as civilians when speaking about cops.

  4. My EDC of choice most of the time is the S&W Shield Plus. But for comfort, I prefer to carry it in a “Simply Things” fanny pack designed for carrying… no shirt to pull up and I’m getting pretty good at the “zip and pull”. My pocket carry for warm days is my tried-and-true Sig P230 .380. For open carry, I like my CZ P10 F in .45 ACP.

  5. The carry gun I purchased when I obtained my concealed carry permit over ten years ago was a Kahr PM9. At the time, it was the best subcompact 9mm one could purchase. The market is now overflowing with 9 mm subcompacts and recently high capacity guns with staggered magazines. Still I stick with my Kahr. After ten years it feels like a sixth finger. I don’t have to think about deploying the gun, it is automatic. Sure, 10 or twelve rounds may be better than 7, but as most gun encounters are three shots at close range, I don’t feel I am at a disadvantage. In 10 years,the Kahr has never failed fo function correctly with any ammo. We are best friends and I am not going to risk our relationship for a few more rounds. If the time comes, I know Kahr will be there. “ That’s what friends
    are for “

  6. I love my full size S&W M&P 2.0 9mm. I love the custom perfect fit grip (pinky hanging off is not for me). Easy to disassemble, easy to rack the slide, and holds 17 rounds. Fit it with a Buris RedDot and a few extra mags just because Gov Inslee said I can’t have them anymore.

  7. OPEN CARRY, IVE GOT THE CANIK TP9 SFX, CONCEALED CARRY THE TP9 ELITE SUB COMPACT. BOTH VERY REASONABLY PRICED, VERY ACCURATE RIGHT OUT OF THE BOX AND ALWAYS RELIABLE. IVE BEEN SHOOTING FOR OVER 40 YRS, OWNED ALOT OF GUNS AND THESE 2 ARE BY FAR MY FAVORITE HANDGUNS EVER! YOU WONT GO WRONG WITH CANIK PRODUCTS

  8. My everyday carry is the shield plus with the 13 rd mags,but when im in shorts i go to my LCP max..love the both but do carry a full size open and my m&p 2.0 45 is my tried and true open carry ..

  9. What size handgun: Well written, covered many of the aspects that newbies are concerned about. As for me, I carry the Ruger LCP, The full-size 1911 .45 ACP by Colt & Kimber, The Kimber Crimson Carry II and the Sig P226. I normally carry the full size 1911s and P226 IWB in leather and kydex holsters in the small of my back as over the years have added poundage and it’s uncomfortable for appendix/side carry. My Sig P226 fits nicely back there and is easily accessible unless I’m seated. I also carry strongarm OWB for all the 1911s and at this moment I’m currently wearing. What we do need are more articles written for conceal carry for women.

  10. You have forgotten a GREAT sub C. I carry subs as well although I have all sizes. My daily carry is either the SR40C or SR9C. Both are accurate out of the box. Both have a 15 round capacity. Both come with a 10 round and a 15 round mag. I carry the 40. I live in Texas and so we don’t have to worry much about concealment or printing.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your discussions, feedback and comments are welcome here as long as they are relevant and insightful. Please be respectful of others. We reserve the right to edit as appropriate, delete profane, harassing, abusive and spam comments or posts, and block repeat offenders. All comments are held for moderation and will appear after approval.