Range Report: FXH .45 — The Hybrid 1911 From ATI

ATI FXH .45 1911 pistol right profile

For some time, American Tactical Imports has offered affordable firearms giving everyone a chance to get into the shooting game. These 1911s may be diamonds in the rough, but they are single-action 1911 handguns, and they are .45s. These GI-type guns have given many shooters on a budget the opportunity to try their hand at Old Slabsides at an exciting price.

ATI FXH .45 1911 pistol right profile
ATI’s FXH .45 is a different type of .45 with many good features.

ATI has introduced a remarkably affordable ‘race gun’ with a polymer frame and steel slide, conventional 1911 controls, and unconventional features. The pistol features a polymer frame with integrated finger grooves. The trigger guard is enlarged. The fit and feel is good.

There are things that may be done with polymer that cannot be done with steel and aluminum. The pistol features a beavertail-type grip safety and target-style trigger, along with an ambidextrous slide-lock safety. The pistol features an accessory rail molded into the frame—making the pistol suited for use with a laser or combat light.

The FXH 45 is a Government Model length pistol with 5-inch barrel. The slide isn’t a GI slide or quite like any other modern slide you have seen. It is black finished stainless according to ATI. It is a very different profile than most 1911 handguns.

FXH .45 pistol's finger grips
Most shooters found the finger grooves gave excellent fit and feel.

The barrel isn’t ported, but the slide has three lightening ports near the muzzle. The sights are modern enough and offer a good sight picture. The front sight is a fiber optic type. It did not work loose on firing several hundred cartridges, so the fiber optic is secure enough. ATI has wisely specified the slide be cut for Glock sights so that you can later fit TruGlo night sights—or your choice of modern night sights or tactical sights.

The slide was designed to allow mounting of the Burris FastFire or other red dot sight. With the use of an adaptor plate, these lights will mount on the slide without drilling and tapping. The result is a race-ready handgun for entry-level competition. The internals are 1911, and as far as I am able to determine, interchange with quality aftermarket 1911 parts.

There are advantages to the polymer frame. These include light weight as the pistol weighs 10 ounces less than a steel frame .45. The ease with which the frame is molded is part of the parcel with polymer.


  • Caliber: .45 ACP
  • Height: 5.4 inches
  • Length: 8.7 inches
  • Weight: 27.5 unloaded
  • Magazine Capacity: 8 rounds

This pistol is as far from the 1911 template as we may venture—and still call the pistol a 1911. The fit and feel are 1911, and while the balance point is near that of a Government Model 1911. At only 30 ounces, the feel is different. It feels like a Commander .45 that points better.

Shooting is what matters. I lubricated the piece with Shooters Choice FP10, and loaded the magazines with my own handloads using the Hornady 185-grain XTP at 890 fps—a pleasant and accurate loading. I supplemented the issue magazine with a pair of MecGar magazines, and then fired 100 rounds as quickly as I could cycle the trigger. It worked just fine.

I fired these without attention to detail as far as accuracy goes but rather firing quickly and getting the feel of the pistol. It isn’t difficult with a handload with modest velocity. Hits were centered on man-sized targets during quick work at 7, 10, and 15 yards.

A few offhand shots at 50 yards showed the pistol has sufficient accuracy for pleasant big bore plinking sessions. I have tested two of these firearms and the first was returned to the factory for trigger adjustment—the match trigger wasn’t engaging—and after I received the FEDEX label, the pistol was returned in four days flat. That is good service.

FXF-45 pistol atop a pair of ear muffs
There were break-in malfunctions, SOP for some 1911 handguns.

The failure of the trigger to drop the hammer should not have happened, but it happens with new guns from time to time. The pistol was purchased retail and no one at ATI knew there was a story forthcoming. The do not know me by name. The service is good; just the way it should be.

The pistol never failed to feed, chamber, fire or eject after a modest break-in period. Be prepared to fire 40-50 full powder cartridges to settle the piece in. The spacious ejection port aids in reliability.

As for my personal handgun, I have fired it with a number of loads during the past few months. The FXH works well for a recreational shooters intended for competition use. The trigger breaks at 7.25 pounds. I would like it to be two to three pounds lighter.

Fiocchi 230-grain FMJ is a quality ball load that offers affordable shooting. I have used this load extensively in practice sessions. Accuracy is good and the handgun is controllable. An estimable defense load is the Fiocchi 230-grain JHP. This is a standard JHP that opens quickly and gives good expansion for home defense use. At 840 fps it is powerful and affordable in 50-round boxes.

fiber optic front sight on a pistol
ATI’s fiber optic front sight is a good feature. It offers real speed in sight acquisition.

The Fiocchi Extrema loading uses the proven XTP bullet. This 230-grain JHP offers a good balance of expansion and penetration favoring penetration. Whichever you prefer, both are accurate. My best results with handloads have been a 2.5-inch group at 25 yards with the FXH 45.

The Fiocchi FMJ loads do about that. The Fiocchi Extrema 230-grain XTP load turned in a singular 1.9-inch group and an average of 2.25 inches. The pistol is accurate enough for most uses. Practical accuracy with lead bullets from Magnus bullets is good.

Is the pistol accurate enough for competition? This is a good beginners handgun. Thirty years ago, I helped a friend set up a Llama Government Model 1911 .45 with parts he purchased used from senior competitors. This young man wrangled a Clark custom barrel and painted the sights. He was able to afford a trigger job.

I was concerned he started out with a pistol known for soft steel, and a handgun I would never trust for personal defense use. The time he spent learning on the Llama was invaluable and really aided in his growth as a shooter. He used it for two years and sold it to a beginner as he moved on to better gear. The ATI FXH is in much the same category but a better gun than the Llama could ever be. It will aid in shooter growth and gives you an optic ready handgun that will not break the bank or destroy matrimonial harmony.

Have you shot the FHX .45? What was your first 1911? Share your answers in the comment section.

About the Author:

Wilburn Roberts

When Wilburn Roberts was a young peace officer, he adopted his present pen name at the suggestion of his chief, as some of the brass was leery of what he might write. This was also adopted out of respect for families of both victims and criminals. The pen name is the same and the man remains an outspoken proponent of using enough gun for the job.

He has been on the hit list of a well-known hate group, traveled in a dozen countries and written on many subjects, including investigating hate crimes and adopting the patrol carbine. He graduated second in his class with a degree in Police Science. It took him 20 years to work himself from Lieutenant to Sergeant and he calls it as he sees it.
The Mission of Cheaper Than Dirt!'s blog, The Shooter's Log, is to provide information—not opinions—to our customers and the shooting community. We want you, our readers, to be able to make informed decisions. The information provided here does not represent the views of Cheaper Than Dirt!

Comments (9)

  1. I am a 1911 enthusiast with Gold Cups, Kimbers, and several STI’s. This gun is by far the best value for the money of any 1911 I have ever shot. It shoots as consistently and as accurately as most of my high end and modified 1911’s for less than half the price. I’m not suggesting it as a replacement for a nice 1911, but this is no beginner’s gun that you are going to outgrow and regret purchasing.

  2. I have sitting beside me a Sar Arms .45ACP pistol. It cost me about $450 at the PX. It has completely adjustable sights (combat sights), a 4.5 inch barrel, steel frame, holds 14 rounds in the magazine, is both single and double action, and shoots around 2″ at 25 yards. It is built along the lines of the CZ 75 with an outside extractor and a loaded chamber indicator. It has about a 9 lb. double action pull, and a 4 lb. or less single action pull, with a short reset. It has an inertial firing pin and can be carried with a round in the chamber and the hammer down, or cocked and locked, either one. It is the least expensive .45 I have seen, and one of the most accurate. You guys might want to take a look at it instead. You can spend a lot more on ammo and a lot less on the weapon than some of the high dollar .45’s.

  3. I have to point out that this thing is absolutely hideous. Why even bother with the 1911 frame if you’re just going to butcher it that badly?

    1. Because the “1911” label comes with automatic love by a significant segment of pistol shooters – and a 20-30% price premium for the manufacturer.

      Besides, beauty is in the eye of the beholder. Not everyone want to spend an extra $500 – $1000 on a pistol just so their friends will think it looks really pretty.

    2. I think it looks extremely cool—like a futuristic 1911 derivative, as it is supposed to. I’m sure it will appeal to some.

  4. First 1911 was a Taurus, only issue I ever had was the ambi-safety broke where it fits together; replaced with a Ed Brown and 5k rounds no issue. Sold it when I closed my business and kept the wife’s Colt 1911. Last year was in a gun shop and saw a used RIA for 275.00. Had feeding issues with the factory mag, switched to the Kimbers the wife gun has and no more trouble. So far I have put a Remington marked ambi on it, spring kit and Dawson night sights approaching 3k rounds without a issue. Next 1911 most likely will be another RIA their pro match ultra in .40 for USPSA shooting- with what I save over a STI I can get a lot of practice in and get to the point to where the STI isa justified

  5. I would love them to make this same gun but less race and more battle, polymer frame double stack with pic rail and all, I believe that would be a winner and very popular with die hard 1911 guys like me to which there are many and have 13-15 rounds of the old thumper at the ready!

  6. I got an ATI FX 1911 Gov. model and threw on $300 of upgrades and still beat the price of RI, Springfield or Ruger 1911’s. Now it looks good and shoots Steel Challenge like a dream.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit exceeded. Please click the reload button and complete the captcha once again.

Your discussions, feedback and comments are welcome here as long as they are relevant and insightful. Please be respectful of others. We reserve the right to edit as appropriate, delete profane, harassing, abusive and spam comments or posts, and block repeat offenders. All comments are held for moderation and will appear after approval.