Review: Cimarron Revolvers — Single Action Army for the Masses

Single Action Army revolver right profile

Among the biggest and most interesting markets for firearms is the cowboy action shooting market. The appetite of the buying public for replicas of the guns of the Old West is a healthy one. The originals are pretty expensive these days. Many were well made of good material, but they are simply are too valuable for most of us to use.

Single Action Army revolver right profile
While some may choose a bright blue finish, the author likes his ‘original finish’ revolver.

Some were made from iron and soft steel. The Colt Single Action Army revolver was the finest handgun of its day with excellent handling and exceptional accuracy. This is the still the single action revolver by which all others are judged. Cimarron offers quality reproductions of the SAA. Uberti of Italy manufactures these revolvers.

Uberti offers many models, imported by several companies. Cimarron has earned a reputation for superior fit and finish among their handguns. I have owned several, and they have given good service. It is interesting to note that the company offers more variations on the SAA revolver than Colt has offered in 145 years of manufacture. These revolvers are not too expensive to use, so you may decide you need a brace of these handguns.

My experience with the Single Action Army dates to my high school years. I purchased a then new name, Uberti, and decided on a 7 ½-inch barrel revolver with a brass grip frame. I played with it more than I fired it and broke some internal parts and the hammer. Repairing the gun was one of my first gunsmithing tasks. I enjoyed firing the .45 and had to handload so I could afford to fire it.

SAA .45 Colt and Double Tap ammunition
The SAA .45 Colt and Double Tap ammunition are ready for serious business.

The Uberti was very accurate with hard cast 250-grain loads. I had the barrel professionally shortened to 4.75 inches. During many lonely days and nights in my college years, this handgun protected my person as I worked security at nights and on the weekends all through school. This job was ideal for me, as I could study and still make the rounds and listen for alarms.

I liked the balance of the Uberti SAA, I felt it balanced better than a four-inch barrel double action .38 revolver and it was considerably more powerful. When I became a peace officer, the Uberti was traded for a Smith and Wesson Combat Masterpiece .38. I did not own another SAA for many years. I have tried the Colt SAA and own a rather nice nickel second generation .45. But the Cimarron is the revolver I fire the most.

There are many variations on the Cimarron Model P as they call it, and some are very nicely finished. They are available in bright blue with case hardened finish and in popular barrel lengths. While there are many variations, the lockwork and attention to detail are the same. Cimarron saw the market for good quality revolvers with authentic appearance. My old Uberti with its brass grip frame and passing fair blue finish with dim case hardening was a useful revolver but not in the class with the modern Cimarron.

My personal revolver is what Cimarron calls the original finish. It is commonly called a distressed finish. The intention is to offer a product that looks a hundred years old when it leaves the factory. Some get it right, some do not, and the Cimarron is one of the latter.

cardboard cranial target with spine
This is an offhand group at 50 feet. The SAA Cimarron is plenty accurate for most chores.

I like the look and this revolver looks like a Wild Bunch gun to me. A note on the action, the single action revolver isn’t safe to carry with six rounds loaded—a cartridge under the firing pin. The hammer-mounted firing pin would strike the cartridge primer if the revolver were dropped.

Modern double action revolvers feature a rebound lever and some have transfer bar systems. There are also single action revolvers with the transfer bar system. They are safe to carry with six rounds in the cylinder. The original type seems to me to have a crisper let off than modern transfer bar actions. It is authentic.

Remember to load only five rounds. The drill is this, load one cartridge, skip a cylinder, load four, cock and lower the hammer and you are on the empty cylinder. Practice this and get it right. There is no other way to carry a single action revolver. As for fast draw, fast draw competitions do not use ball ammo. Instead they use blanks. There is no real need to practice a fast draw and it didn’t happen in the old west that often either. If you do need to draw quickly, get on target before cocking the hammer. Never cock the hammer in the holster.

My revolver is a 5 ½-inch barrel version. I have tried the 4 ¾-inch gunfighter’s version and also the long barrel revolver. After many years of using the SAA, I find the 5 ½-inch barrel length is overall the best balanced and handling for my needs.

Bob campbell shooting a single action army revolver right
The SAA is well balanced and fast handling.

This revolver is very accurate, posting five-shot 2-inch groups at 25 yards with the Fiocchi 250-grain lead load. This bullet is of a hard alloy that takes the rifling well and results in less leading than most cowboy action loads. At just under 800 fps this is a useful all-around loading for cowboy action and informal target practice. It is also affordable in 50 round boxes.

The .45 Colt responds well to a careful handloader. I have used hard cast 250-grain SWC bullets with excellent results, primarily from Magnus cast bullets. Using WW231 powder for 850 fps, the .45 Colt is useful for use well past 50 yards. I have also loaded heavier loads using WW231 and Titegroup for 900 to 920 fps.

The .45 Colt isn’t as powerful as the .44 Magnum, but for the weight of the revolver, and the power of the cartridge, it is a useful piece for defense against all but the largest animals. A factory load that offers plenty of power is the Double Tap Ammunition 255-grain hard cast SWC. This one exits the Cimarron’s 5 ½-inch barrel at 896 fps.

Galco Wheelgunner holster with Single Action Army revolver
The Galco Wheelgunner is an excellent holster.

I often carry this load in the revolver when hiking in the mountains and fields. I have also used a handload with the Hornady 250-grain XTP bullet at 830 fps. So far, this is the single most accurate loading I have fired in the Cimarron, offering 25-yard, five-shot groups of less than two inches. I use Titegroup powder for this application.

Carrying the SAA has been made a lot easier with the introduction of the GALCO Wheelgunner. This holster is well made of quality steer leather. The Wheelgunner is reversible and may be worn on the right or left side. There is a crossdraw option. The Wheelgunner also offers an easy on and off option.

While it is tight enough for most uses without a safety strap, there is a hammer thong for greater security. If you need the revolver quickly, the thong is easily flipped over the hammer as you draw. I like this holster very much and find it has much utility for outdoors and range use.

The Cimarron revolvers are well made of good material, accurate, and powerful. I enjoy mine very much and so will you.

Are you a Cowboy Action revolver fan? Do you own a Cimarron Single Action Army revolver? What caliber and finish? Share your answers in the comment section.

About the Author:

Bob Campbell

Bob Campbell’s primary qualification is a lifelong love of firearms, writing, and scholarship. He holds a degree in Criminal Justice but is an autodidact in matters important to his readers. Campbell considers unarmed skills the first line of defense and the handgun the last resort. (He gets it honest- his uncle Jerry Campbell is in the Boxer’s Hall of Fame.)

Campbell has authored well over 6,000 articles columns and reviews and fourteen books for major publishers including Gun Digest, Skyhorse and Paladin Press. Campbell served as a peace officer and security professional and has made hundreds of arrests and been injured on the job more than once.

He has written curriculum on the university level, served as a lead missionary, and is desperately in love with Joyce. He is training his grandchildren not to be snowflakes. At an age when many are thinking of retirement, Bob is working a 60-hour week and awaits being taken up in a whirlwind many years in the future.

Published in
Black Belt Magazine
Combat Handguns
Rifle Magazine
Gun Digest
Gun World
Tactical World
SWAT Magazine
American Gunsmith
Gun Tests Magazine
Women and Guns
The Journal Voice of American Law Enforcement
Police Magazine
Law Enforcement Technology
The Firearms Instructor
Tactical World
Concealed Carry Magazine
Concealed Carry Handguns

Books published

Holsters for Combat and Concealed Carry
The 1911 Automatic Pistol
The Handgun in Personal Defense
The Illustrated Guide to Handgun Skills
The Hunter and the Hunted
The Gun Digest Book of Personal Defense
The Gun Digest Book of the 1911
The Gun Digest Book of the 1911 second edition
Dealing with the Great Ammunition Shortage
Commando Gunsmithing
The Ultimate Book of Gunfighting
Preppers Guide to Rifles
Preppers Guide to Shotguns
The Accurate Handgun
The Mission of Cheaper Than Dirt!'s blog, The Shooter's Log, is to provide information—not opinions—to our customers and the shooting community. We want you, our readers, to be able to make informed decisions. The information provided here does not represent the views of Cheaper Than Dirt!

Comments (17)

  1. I own a Cimarron Army Scout ( nickel plate- 7 1/2 inch barrel black powder frame ) . A beautiful gun. In fact, I consider it flawless. I also have a Uberti Model P .22 rimfire with a 12 shot cylinder. It’s very nice too but even using quality ammunition after a couple of cylinders fired, it clogs up with powder residue and has to be cleaned out before the cylinder will rotate again . I don’t fire it much anymore for that reason but it’s still a quality gun .

  2. I have the Cimarron Bad Boy in .44 magnum, 6″ barrel. It kicks like a mule, but that’s what makes it a blast.

  3. After reading this and watching a few videos I bought one! 4 3/4 barrel chambered in .357 mag. I’ll be seeing it in about a week and then the ten day wait but excited to get into single action. Figured this revolver would be a good start. Especially at around 500 bucks! Great article Bob!

  4. “Some get it right, some do not, and the Cimarron is one of the latter.”

    So you don’t like the finish on the Cimarron? It seemed odd to leave this out there without reinforcing it with what you don’t like about it is why I ask.

  5. My Cimarron Model P is the gunfighter with the color case hardened receiver and the old – bright – blue nitre (known today as charcoal blued) barrel. I cannot adequately describe the beauty of this gun. Among my relatively large collection, it is like the shapely blonde who walks into the bar at closing time in an outfit that is so clingy it would have to be peeled off. The gun is that stunning!

    And the detail of the parts is so close to original that it takes someone more exp[ert than me to explain the few differences from the original 1873 model.

    For now, I keep taking it out of the safe to ogle it.

    Hopefully soon I will shoot it.

  6. Hello,

    I realize that this thread was from a few months ago but it is right along with what I am looking for…..

    My question is due to the fact that the Uberti manufactured SAA clone smokeless cartridge revolvers use modern steel isnt it perfectly safe for the shooter and the gun to use SAAMI Factory Spec NON-+P ammunition by Hornady, Remington, Winchester, BuffaloBore, DoubleTap, Corbon, UnderWood, HSM, Grizzly, etc??

    Thank you

  7. I have the exact gun. For some reason, my7.5″ looks longer.
    Mine was probably purchased later than yours, but keeping 6 in
    does not seem to be a problem for me. There is a “safe carry”
    position just off the hammer seat that I keep it on.
    It’s the first click you can hear, and will protect even if dropped
    on the hammer. Cimarron used to part number it “514AF”
    for Antique Finish

  8. I own two .45 Colt revolvers, Rugers, Bisley-Vaquero, 5.5-inch, and Redhawk, .45 Auto/.45 Colt. 4.2-inch.
    I’ve had a love affair with the .45 Colt cartridge since boyhood and enjoy shooting and reloading for them. I cast 200-grain SWC, 250-grain and 255-grain round-flat point bullets from Linotype. ( I have to, the price of this ammo is far too expensive for me! )
    For those who don’t roll their own, I saw a box of 250 rounds of 255-grain, flat point, 800 fps made by American Quality. It comes to only $22.94 per 50 in their bulk pack. Hope that helps some of the .45 Colt fans out there!
    HJ Braud

  9. I love the “spaghetti six shooters” made by Uberti. I have never owned a Cimarron, but I read that they have a good reputation. I own Uberti’s “Cody” model my self (I would have preferred a blued an case hardened gun, but the Cody was available for a good price, and anyway it looks like the Lone Ranger’s gun! LOL). The 5 1/2 barrel hold on target very well and is a great shooter. I mostly shoot the Blazer aluminum cased JSP round through my gun because I don’t reload and those rounds tend to sell for less.

  10. I am by no means a cowboy action shooter but I did purchase a Uberti El Patron Competition model in .357. It is an impressive pistol that is quite accurate. Probably more accurate than I will ever be able to shoot it, and its as much a work of art as it is a revolver.
    My other SA is a Ruger Blackhawk chambered in .30 carbine that was made, according to the serial number, around 1972. I adapted it for scope use with a Weaver 301 mount and put a Vortex 2moa Crossfire on top of it. Its kinda fun busting clay pigeons at 50 to 75 feet.

  11. What a beauty. Love that finish. I have a .45 colt chambered firearm and I do appreciate the softer recoil ( I think of it as feeling like a slower push). And I’m glad to hear of your success at using modern loads on this venerable weapon. I’ve never owned a Single Action Army and have always considered the reloading process to be tedious. But then I think back to when I was about eight years old and “borrowed” my older brother’s Mattel Fanner Fifty cap gun, a spitting image replica of the ’73 Colt.

  12. I think the quote “Some get it right, some do not, and the Cimarron is one of the latter.” when discussing the finish is reversed unless you mean to say the Cimarron does not get the the distressed finish done correctly. Otherwise I think the article is great

  13. “My personal revolver is what Cimarron calls the original finish. It is commonly called a distressed finish. The intention is to offer a product that looks a hundred years old when it leaves the factory. Some get it right, some do not, and the Cimarron is one of the latter.”

    This statement says that the Cimarron does not look like a vintage gun. Using the word “latter” implies that your pistol did not get it right. If they had, the proper choice would have been “former”. I would consider correcting this as well as proofreading the entire article to catch all the other errors in grammar and sentence structure.

    Just getting tired of lazy ad writers…PM

  14. I have 2 ruger bird head revolvers with buffalo horn grips. Wearing them in they’re double holsters, takes me back to the days of watching a good western with my dad. Fun to shoot and sometimes males you feel like John Wayne.

  15. While I do not own a Cimarron, I do own a few SAA “thumb-buster” revolvers. Probably the most accurate of which is my Ruger single-action six convertible in .22 & .22 mag (which is as accurate as my K38 Smith revolver). The most powerful SAA is my Ruger single-action six convertible in .38-40 & 10mm (which is more fun to shoot than my .44 mag. model 29 Smiths – one 6″ and one 8-3/8″ – although not as powerful). Then there is my Old West 1875 Schofield Top-Break replica by Uberti in .38 special – just for fun. Not having a Cimarron SAA, I don’t think I have missed much.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your discussions, feedback and comments are welcome here as long as they are relevant and insightful. Please be respectful of others. We reserve the right to edit as appropriate, delete profane, harassing, abusive and spam comments or posts, and block repeat offenders. All comments are held for moderation and will appear after approval.

Discover more from The Shooter's Log

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading