Range Report: Springfield Emissary 1911 9mm Commander

Eve Flanagan shooting the Springfield Emissary 1911 Commander size 1911 9mm semi automatic pistol

Springfield Armory allowed me the gift of testing its new edition of the eye-catching Emissary 1911 before its May 2022 release. Their earlier version of this gun is a government-size 45 ACP. The newest Emissary is Commander-sized and chambered in 9mm with a 4.25-inch barrel. It’s definitely not a run-of-the-mill 1911. Read on to find out why.

Springfield Emissary Features

Sure, a 1911 is the definition of a traditional platform. But this one is different — inside and out. That much is obvious at first glance. Its profile and appearance are more steampunk than old Army style. Let’s start with the unique, angular slide. It has a narrow top, grooved for glare control, with a plain black, narrow U-notch rear sight and orange/tritium up front. The sides of the slide drop off like the roofline of a Victorian house, settling into vertical sidewalls to make a hexagon of sorts.

4.5-inch Springfield Emissary Commander-size 9mm 1911 handgun
The 4.5-inch Emissary is a Commander-size rendition of Springfield’s original Emissary, a government-size chambered in 45 ACP. This one is 9mm.

There are fairly standard slide serrations aft of the ejection port and up front, and three decorative notches on the angled surface. The slide has bluing for finish. Its sleek surface is eye-catching and shows the fingerprints of anyone who ventures to fondle or shoot the gun. A brushed stainless frame provides contrast for the striking, dark-colored components. It’s almost impossible to get tired of looking at this pistol thanks to the richness and contrast of textures.

Also, unlike anything else is the trigger guard. It’s not rounded like a normal 1911; nor is it squared off like most striker guns. It’s square-ish, big enough for gloved operation, and sports a rounded outer corner. Likewise, the trigger is more about making its own style than following trends. I’ve not seen anything like it. It’s solid black, and lightweight polymer or G10, and not finely curved like some that follow the current trend of skeletonized 1911 triggers.

Keeping with unapologetically unique style is the texture of the Emissary’s grips, front strap, and backstrap. When my FFL handed the box to me, he said, “This is rough!” I soon found out what he meant. There’s no need to add traction on these grips. The G10 grips are very aggressively sculpted, guaranteeing a solid purchase on what little recoil this gun delivers.

Also unique is the fact that the grip panels are flat in profile, whereas most are fatter in the middle. This is a grip trait I’ve been wanting since I owned my first 1911, and a request to which more than one grip-maker and gunsmith have responded with side-eye. Springfield finally delivered! As a result, my small/medium-size hands have no problem reliably depressing the grip safety and my thumb reaches the slide lock without excess effort. Hallelujah!

Stainless steel components, including a crowned, heavy bull barrel, make this gun a heavy one. Along with 9mm chambering, recoil is negligible. Its silvery/black contrast finish, significant heft, and rough grip texture make operating, and even just looking at, the Emissary a unique and memorable experience in a market that’s chock-full of endless, but less remarkable, interpretations of the platform.

inside view of the Springfield Emissary's slide and frame
A look inside the Emissary’s forged carbon steel frame and slide. Like the barrel, they are weighty and lend weight that results in soft recoil.

The safety, trigger, and takedown lever are black polymer and contrast nicely with the silver/black theme. Likewise, the beavertail and skeletonized hammer are black.

Range Time

With a good variety of sponsored ammunition, we were able to test the Emissary’s reliability with some degree of confidence. Each type was cycled-through at least once with a full magazine in rapid-fire. We returned to slow-fire with four or five rounds of each brand mixed in the mag to see if mid-stream changes would make a difference in feeding/extraction. Only one problem was encountered among the following loads:

  • Federal American Eagle Lead-Free 75-grain
  • TulAmmo 115-grain steel case FMJ
  • Hornady Critical Defense 115-grain JHP
  • Winchester USA Ready Defense 124-grain +P JHP
  • SIG Sauer M17 124-grain +P JHP
  • Federal Premium HST Tactical 147-grain

All these rounds cycled through mag dumps without issue. However, the SIG Sauer M17 incurred a failure to go into battery upon the initial loading. Both testers noted the slide being sluggish to load, and we loaded not just by releasing the slide lock, but by pulling the slide rearward to fully compress the recoil spring. The slide ran fine for actual firing, though.

Inserting the Allen wrench at the bottom of the barrel of the Springfield Emissary 1911 9mm pistol
A pin inserted in the recoil spring housing, while the slide is pulled back, releases the spring and guide rod from inside the slide for disassembly.

Thanks to day-after-day of persistent high winds, it was only fair to the gun to forgo a serious grouping test, since the targets were in constant motion. Given that, the Emissary has a quality bull barrel, and that its .45 ACP predecessor is known for outstanding precision, it’s safe to assume this 9mm edition is above average in the accuracy department.

The nine-round mags (two included) dropped freely from the mag well regardless of load status. I consider this an essential feature, and the Emissary has it. Loading ammo into the mags requires a bit of effort to ensure each round is fully seated at the rear of the magazine. For those who struggle to load, the day-saving Uplula Universal Magazine Loader works well with the 9mm Emissary mags.

sights and top profile of the Springfield Emissary 9mm 1911 semiautomatic handgun
A look at the sights and top profile of the Emissary. The front sight has tritium for dim-light shooting. The slide has unusual angles and decorative molding in front of the ejection port. Blued and glossy, the slide is part of the gun’s overall futuristic appearance.

The left side-only safety is easy to operate. This is so much the case that I find it necessary, when shooting right-handed, to grip with the right thumb atop the safety to prevent unintended engagement. In terms of personal preference, I think it’s set just right, as opposed to having a safety that requires effort to get the gun running.

That reminds me to comment on keeping this gun running. Springfield provides a little Allen wrench to disassemble the Emissary. The user manual advises a simple thin paper clip can suffice for it. Takedown entails holding the slide back to a matching notch on the frame, and then inserting the Allen wrench through the holes in the recoil spring housing. This permits the removal of the recoil spring and barrel from the underside of the slide.

Reassembly is the simple reversal of this process. I found the procedure simple after looking at a YouTube video showing the process on a .45 ACP Emissary. The user manual diagram lacked sufficient detail for my non-mechanic’s mind to understand the process.

Specs: Springfield Emissary 4.25-inch 9mm

Chambering: 9mm Luger
Barrel: 4.25-inch forged stainless steel, match grade, fully supported ramp, bull, 1:16 twist
Slide: Forged carbon steel, blued
Frame: Forged carbon steel
Recoil system: Commander length
Overall length: 7.75 inches
Overall height: 5.25 inches
Weight: 2.5 pounds


Springfield outdid itself at creating the crossroads of performance and style with the Emissary series. I’m pleased to see this 9mm line extension, which makes the gun more inviting to shoot from both a physical and ammo availability perspective. It takes a bit more coin to make this one yours than the average 9mm 1911. But it’s a fair price for the upgrade in above-average accuracy and looks.

4.5-inch Springfield Armory Emissary 1911 9mm handgun left profile on a fire hydrant
The 4.5-inch Emissary by Springfield Armory is the latest in its relatively new Emissary series. It is chambered in 9mm and ships with two 9-round magazines.

I see this gun as being ideal for the guy or gal who wants to best their buddies at bullseye shooting, or the open carrier who wants a reliable and eye-catching defensive gun. For the weekend recreational shooter, there’s something to be said for having a gun everyone wants to look at and that everyone can easily shoot.

During the trial period, I encountered a friend at the range who has a copy of this gun in 45 ACP. He spoke highly of its performance and was pleased to show it off. The 4.25-inch, 9mm Emissary has a suggested retail price of $1,349; market prices should come in lower.

Springfield believes it has raised the bar with the release of the Emissary 9mm in a Commander size and if past sales are an indication, it should be an immediate hit. However, you have the final say. Are you excited about the new Springfield Emissary 9mm 1911? Share your answer in the comment section.

  • Eve Flanagan shooting the Springfield Emissary 1911 Commander size 1911 9mm semi automatic pistol
  • 4.5-inch Springfield Emissary Commander-size 9mm 1911 handgun
  • sights and top profile of the Springfield Emissary 9mm 1911 semiautomatic handgun
  • Rough texture on the Emissary’s grip panels
  • inside view of the Springfield Emissary's slide and frame
  • forged, stainless, crowned bull barrel for the Springfield Emissary 9mm 1911 semi automatic pistol
  • Inserting the Allen wrench at the bottom of the barrel of the Springfield Emissary 1911 9mm pistol
  • 4.5-inch Springfield Armory Emissary 1911 9mm handgun left profile on a fire hydrant
The Mission of Cheaper Than Dirt!'s blog, The Shooter's Log, is to provide information—not opinions—to our customers and the shooting community. We want you, our readers, to be able to make informed decisions. The information provided here does not represent the views of Cheaper Than Dirt!

Comments (11)

  1. The point is choice. A tri-top 9mm with u-dot tritium front sight, ledge rear sights, thin profile g10 grenade grips, a flat trigger, skeletonized hammer, bull barrel (a significant difference from other offerings) front strap and mhs “checkering” for lack of better description (in a good way), and a weight to make recoil even less than a standard 9mm 1911, all make this pistol a sweet shooter. If you turn away on account of looks, enjoy the ol slabslides. Your opinion is understandable and I can’t argue with you. There will always be a poetry in the lines of a legacy 1911. But if you turn away from it for any other reason, you’re missing out on the advantages of an out-of-box mid-cost platform with features most often found on custom guns three, sometimes four times the msrp and up. I also bought It’s big brother in God’s Caliber (admittedly for looks and as a host for my TLR9) and found myself shooting that even more often than my SW1911PC, which I considered my favorite right up until last month. I’f you’re on the fence, hop over it and give this thing a shot.

  2. It’s a cute 1911 I suppose, but let’s get real I’m sure since it’s a Springfield the price is outta sight for most and with all the “modernizations” it don’t seem worth it…the old adage if it ain’t broke don’t fix it well they dun broke it and fixed it wrong… I’ll stick with my rock island 3.5in 45acp with a bottom rail…until I get the same one in 9mm

  3. Not impressed with this weapon. I’ve got a couple Springfield firearms including a range officer elite (commander) in 45 as a CCW and love it. But even with an aluminum frame, it gets heavy on the hip during long days. Why they’d come up with a 9mm in steel frame makes me wonder. Not impressed with the finish on this weapon either. Looks like a high school metal shop production. Jmo

  4. A Smith and Wesson Light weight Commander is a ” Carry Gun “. This is not. Too Many Sharp Edges, too heavy, too square, and too hard to disassemble for cleaning.

    The square corners on the slide and trigger guard negates 90% of the existing holster on the market today.

    This gun is a waste.

  5. I was surprised to see the small imperfections in the mold of the flat rear part of the upper. It looks like it should have at least been smoothed out. Does it say something about the quality control? I’ve owned a Colt .45 Defender for more than 20 years, and I wouldn’t trade it for anything. Granted it’s been fairly customized. Like this new Springfield, I do wish there was the option for mounting a heads up red dot. And it didn’t look like it had the bottom rails for mounting a light. That’s why I bought a Walther 9mm for home defense. Totally tricked out. But I still love my short 1911! And the grips…they may help with stability, but you can get stability without having your hand ground down like minced meat. It just looks like too much. And I hate having to have a tool to disassemble the gun. There are times (more combat oriented) where you don’t want to have to look for a tool to be able to clean the gun. That’s just a personal preference. And maybe I’m reading this wrong, but I didn’t understand the writer when she wrote, when shooting right-handed, “I preferred to grip with the right thumb atop the safety to prevent unintended engagement. Wouldn’t having pressure on the safety allow for accidental releasing of the safety, making the gun “hot.” I’ll have to see, and shoot, this one before I’m ready to make a decision.

  6. Seems there are two classes of 1911; The classic style, and the modern day style. In the latter, if one updates the style to fall into the modern day style, like this one, seems a light rail would also be standard, and possibly even a removable optic plate. I know I wish the SR1911, at least had the option choice, had a light rail on it, to make it an even greater home defense unit.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your discussions, feedback and comments are welcome here as long as they are relevant and insightful. Please be respectful of others. We reserve the right to edit as appropriate, delete profane, harassing, abusive and spam comments or posts, and block repeat offenders. All comments are held for moderation and will appear after approval.

Discover more from The Shooter's Log

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading