The AR-10 and AR-15 — What are the Differences?

Del Ton AR-10 sitting on a tan hardcase

When Dr. Dave Dolbee and I discussed this article, the wheels in my mind were whirling. I have used each platform, find both to be great guns, and think everyone should own more than one of each. However, the how and why I came to this conclusion need to be explained.

Del Ton AR-10 sitting on a tan hardcase
The Del Ton AR-10 is an affordable .308 with good performance.

As far as handling and ergonomics, each is brilliantly designed and the function is the same. Some new shooters may not realize that the AR-10 7.62x51mm rifle came first. This .308 rifle competed with the FN FAL and M14. In the end, the rifle was downsized into the .223 caliber AR-15.

The primary difference between the rifles is the caliber. The AR-10 is chambered for the .308 Winchester or 7.62x51mm NATO. The AR-15 chambers the .223 Remington or 5.56mm NATO cartridge. There are others, but the big ones, such as the .300 Short Magnum, must be chambered in the AR-10. The .308 replaced the .30-06 as a sniper and machine gun cartridge, and still serves today.

Sale ends July 28, 2019

Sale ends July 28, 2019

There are also many M14 rifles serving. The rifle has been referred to as shoulder-fired artillery overseas, compared to the .223. To the best of my knowledge, there are no AR-10s in military service. The .308 usually has a 1:11-inch twist; the .223 in modern rifles may feature a number of twists, but 1:8 seems most common. Both (usually) feature a 16-inch barrel.

The AR-15 was a response to the Russian AK-47 we encountered in Vietnam. The lighter AK was controllable in automatic fire and more ammunition could be carried than the M14 allowed, putting our soldiers at a disadvantage. President Kennedy ordered the AK-47 tested against the AR-15. The rifle was controversial and early versions suffered due to the powder combination used in the initial ammunition issued.

Fieldstripped AR-10 rifle
The AR-10 features a massive bolt and heavier internal parts.

The rifle continued to serve and was developed into the present AR-15/M4 rifle. The new AR-10s are usually a 1.5 pounds heavier than the AR-15 and about three inches longer, due to the heavier receiver and longer stock. The AR-10 fires a stronger cartridge with more momentum, so you could not simply re-barrel the AR-15.

The bolt, bolt carrier, and springs must be heavier to accommodate the .308 Winchester. The AR-15 may accept a 20- or 30-round magazine, the AR-10 usually deploys a 20-round magazine. The decision is—do you wish to deploy a heavier rifle that is more powerful, or to maintain the AR-15 rifle—which is plenty powerful for most choices.

If you hunt medium game, the .308 is the better choice by far. It is effective against deer-sized animals well past 200 yards. You will get into a solid position and take the shot. If you are varmint hunting, the .223 AR-15 is the better choice. You may be firing more quickly in rapid movement. For personal and home defense, the AR-15 is the better choice based on ease of control and modest penetration in a home defense situation.

The .308 has greater wound potential, knockdown power, and penetration. At close range, the .223 is designed to fragment. A 55-grain bullet at 3,200 fps produces a tremendous wound. The problem, as velocity slows the rifle becomes less effective. The rule of thumb is the .223 loses much of its effectiveness at 100 to 125 yards. The .223 is very effective at close range with the proper loads, especially with multiple shots. The .223 will carry more ammunition for an equal weight. The .308 is the better choice for designated marksman rifles intended to be used past 100 yards.

Industry Armament AR-10 rifle left profile
This Industry Armament AR-10 rifle features an 18-inch barrel and modern handguard.

When you get down to brass tacks, the difference between the two rifles boils down to caliber and the intended mission. The AR-10 is more powerful, heavier, and holds less ammunition. The AR-15 is lighter and holds more ammunition. Inside of 100 yards, the .223 is plenty effective on man-sized threats.

Ammunition is cheap and plentiful for the .223, and there are more ammo choices. For personal defense—9 times out of 10—the AR-15 is the better choice. For those living on the plains or needing a good hunting rifle that may double in the area defense role, the AR-10 is a great choice.

As for accuracy there are true tack drivers in either configuration. I have not fired a dog in either that I can recall. As far as reliability and functionality, this is more a product of the ammunition, how clean it burns, and shooter maintenance.

Effectiveness for Home and Area Defense

.223 loads expand or fragment, producing wounds that result in immediate cessation of hostile action. This makes for a safer load for home defense. The .308 may punch through a threat, while doing less damage. While there are modern, purpose-designed .308 loads that produce good wound ballistics, the .223 remains the load of choice at shorter range. The .308 is the long-range rifle.

Hornady .308 cartridge drawing
The .308 Winchester as loaded by Hornady Ammunition offers excellent all around performance.

There are interesting things going on in either variation. As an example, the .224 Valkyrie, as developed by Federal Cartridge Company, is giving AR-15 fans an option that may shooter flatter than the 6.5 Creedmoor. Time will tell which will be more popular in the future.

At present the AR-15 is far more numerous. The AR-10 has a loyal, but smaller, following. Carefully study your needs and choose well. There are well-made rifles among each type that serve a real purpose.

Do you prefer the AR-10 or AR-15 for personal defense? Which model is your favorite? Share your answers in the comment section.


The Mission of Cheaper Than Dirt!'s blog. "The Shooter's Log", is to provide information - not opinions - to our customers and the shooting community. We want you, our readers, to be able to make informed decicions. The information provided here does not represent the views of Cheaper Than Dirt!

Comments (17)

  1. I have several AR15’s and an AR10. I’m an avid deer hunter and my AR10 has replaced my 30-30 and .270 as my white tail rifle. I really think that the .308 is as close to the perfect caliber there is,esp.hunting in Texas.

  2. I shoot both. Either one is excellent. I use the 15 for varments and target shooting. I use the 10 for white tail deer. I have downed deer beyond 250 yards. Both are very dependable.

  3. I dont agree with the statement the 5.56 is only good out to 125 yards. I have an ar pistol with 10.5″ barrel and can regularly knock down a 12″ plate at 235 yards.

  4. I built, what I consider, a high end AR 10. I wanted a medium range paper puncher essentially. I was disappointed. I expected moa or better. Didn’t get it.
    Then I built a .458 socom for fun. Realizing there would be no joy with that unless I started reloading. I started reloading.
    While I had plenty of .308 ammo, I thought “golly gee”, maybe I’ll load some myself and just see. Bingo! I had my sub moa punch.
    I love the thing. Too heavy to be practical at about 15 lbs, but lots O fun.

  5. Have both colt mt 6400 and windham ar10 in .308..The ar15 is my home defence. The ar10 in 308 with shooting sticks is s meat killer
    JS Texas

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit exceeded. Please click the reload button and complete the captcha once again.

Your discussions, feedback and comments are welcome here as long as they are relevant and insightful. Please be respectful of others. We reserve the right to edit as appropriate, delete profane, harassing, abusive and spam comments or posts, and block repeat offenders. All comments are held for moderation and will appear after approval.