Windham Weaponry — Today’s Best AR-15 or Clone?

Windham Weaponry AR15 SRC M4A4 Rifle

Whether or not you could be considered an AR aficionado, Windham Weaponry would not likely be the first manufacturer that comes to mind. In fact, I would suspect most are searching their memory banks trying to recall if they have ever even heard of Windham Weaponry. Rest at ease, the name is not as important as who is behind it and the quality of workers building the guns.

Once upon a time, a small AR manufacturing company was conceived in Windham, Maine. It went through a few owners and changes before relocating to Ilion, New York — talk about a stake to the heart. Eventually, New York proved fatal (insert my shocked face here) and the workers lost their jobs. Now, back when the company was first started, in Maine by it original owner, Richard Dyke — yes, the same Richard Dyke who started Bushmaster Firearms International — it was successful. Is it starting to get interesting now?

Windham Weaponry SRC AR-15 M4A4
The Windham Weaponry SRC features an M4A4-style flat-top design with a Picatinny rails ready for your favorite optics.

This whole process took about 5 years. Dyke’s non-compete contract was set to expire and he was ready to save the company — in Maine, not New York, of course — and Windham Weaponry was born. Dyke made the necessary moves to open and looked to bring back as many of the original employees as possible. I do not know how many of the major players in the AR industry are shaking in their boots, but they are all taking notice.

Early 2012

Windham Weaponry hit the ground with four primary rifle configurations; today it offers 10. The first Windham model to <ahem> land in my hands — because I certainly did not swipe it from the boss’s desk while in the restroom — was the SRC, formally known as the Windham Model R16M4FTT “SRC”.

SRC Features

The SRC features an M4A4-style flat-top design with a Picatinny rail. There is another two-inch Picatinny incorporated onto the gas block. This gives you a host of sight/optic options that can be easily added or removed, but it should be noted as a flat top configuration, the SRC is shipped sans sights.

The SRC is a semi-automatic rifle that relies on a gas-impingement system to cycle the action. The receiver is made from forged 7075 T6 aircraft aluminum and decked with a black anodized finish. I am not sure how much of a difference it makes, but I like that Windham still features an aluminum trigger over the polymer versions used on many of today’s ARs.

The SRC is equipped with a chrome-lined steel 16-inch barrel with M4 profile and removable A2 flash suppressor. The factory handguard is of the M4 double heat shield variety and the pistol grip is an A2 black plastic model. I still have my first Bushmaster with a plastic handguard, but in reality this would be one of the first pieces I’d replace. I do not typically hang a bunch of furniture, but I like the option to be available.

The rest is pretty much standard fare. The SRC comes with a six-position, telescoping shoulder stock (with Windham logo) and all controls are what you would expect and where it should be for an AR. Likewise, nothing outside of the norm is required to fieldstrip, clean, or lube the SRC. Oh yeah, it ships stock with a 30 rounder for those living in areas where legal.

Bushmaster Clone?

It certainly feels comfortable, similar to one of my Bushmasters, but I would not go so far as to call it a clone. All ARs share a family genealogy to some degree and most people would have to flip one over and read the logo to be sure which one was in their hand anyway. The difference is in the specs, particularly at key points — while striving to keep the platform at a competitive price point. At this, my SRC excels on both points.

My (-boss’s, as I have just been reminded) unit was ding-free without any tool marks or chattering. The fit was tight and controls were of standard size. I did not see where any corners were cut to save money, as has been the case on a few cheap imports I have played with over the years. Most important, the trigger was crisp and broke smoothly right out of the box.

Windham Weaponry AR15 SRC M4A4 Rifle
The barrel features a 1:9 twist rate and should be best suited to bullets weighing 45 to 69 grains. Your ideal weight will be determined by the intended purpose, hunting, self-defense and how well your gun likes a particular round.

You would think that it would be easy to get the boss to cough up a 1,000 or so rounds for a range test working for Cheaper Than Dirt, but it seems y’all are buying our stock too quick. So, I had to go with Plan B. At the range and in talking with a few gun nuts, I would put the Windham SRC at just over an MOA gun. Likely, you are looking at something in the neighborhood of 1.25- to 1.5-inch groups (five-shot) at 100 yards and from a solid rest.

Twist rates can matter and certain guns just like to eat a particular brand of bullet over another, so results will vary. With a bit of testing, I am sure you could bring down those numbers and get better group sizes. Maybe add a receiver buffer and a few other accuracy tricks. Either way, the SRC shoots better than the AR standard of minute-of-clay-pigeon and I do not intend to use it as a bench rest gun anyway.

A bunch of testing that I would enjoy (if the boss would pay for it) would really only prove which round shoots best out of one particular serial number. The 1:9 from a 16-inch barrel is suited for anything in the 45- to 69-grain range, so the best I can do is look to Uncle Sam for his recommendation:

In 1977, NATO members signed an agreement to select a second, smaller caliber cartridge to replace the 7.62 mm NATO cartridge. Of the cartridges tendered, the 5.56×45mm was successful, but not the 55-gr. M193 round used by the U.S. at that time. The wounds produced by the M193 round were so devastating that many consider it to be inhumane.

Instead, the Belgian 62-gr. SS109 round was chosen for standardization. The SS109 used a heavier bullet with a steel core and had a lower muzzle velocity for better long-range performance, specifically to meet a requirement that the bullet be able to penetrate through one side of a steel helmet at 600 meters. This requirement made the SS109 (M855) round less capable of fragmentation than the M193 and was considered more humane.

I guess that means I’ll have to choose something topped with a 55 grain known for accuracy. How about you?

Features and Specifications:

  • Manufacturer: Windham Weaponry —
  • Model: R16M4FTT — SRC
  • Action: Semi-Automatic, Gas Impingement System
  • Caliber: .223 Rem / 5.56mm NATO
  • Safety: Manual Lever with Indicator Markings on Both Sides of Receiver
  • Receiver: M4A4 Type Flat Top Upper Receiver
  • Receiver Material: Forged 7075 T6 Aircraft Aluminum with Aluminum Trigger Guard
  • Receiver Finish: Hardcoat Black Anodized Finish
  • Barrel: 16” M4 Profile, Chrome Lined with A2 Flash Suppressor
  • Barrel Material: 4150 Chrome Moly Vanadium Steel
  • Shoulder Stock: 6-Position Telescoping Buttstock
  • Pistol Grip: A2 Black Polymer
  • Forend: M4 Double Heat Shield
  • Sights: None
  • Overall Length: 34.5” (30” with the stock collapsed)
  • Weight: 6.3 lbs. Without Magazine
  • Capacity: 30+1 Rounds, Ships with one 30-Round Magazine
  • Twist: 1:9″ RH
  • Accessories: Plastic Hard Case, Web Sling, Operators Manual
  • Warranty: Limited Lifetime for Original Owner, but Transferrable
  • Suggested Retail Price: $1040, but we don’t like suggestions – Our Price $859
The Mission of Cheaper Than Dirt!'s blog, The Shooter's Log, is to provide information—not opinions—to our customers and the shooting community. We want you, our readers, to be able to make informed decisions. The information provided here does not represent the views of Cheaper Than Dirt!

Comments (80)

  1. Bought SRC during 4th of July sale, what a great gun. Eats anything I feed it, shoots great groups, Great value for the money, would recommend it to anyone, my favorite rifle.

  2. I have recently purchased a Windham Arms rifle second hand. The Model # does not show on your website. I would like to know the date of manufacture and the configuration of the rifle as shipped. Any help would be most appreciated.

    Model # is WW-CF.

  3. I’ve owned a Windham MPC since the first year it came out, and it has been a super reliable rifle that shoots anything I feed it. If you harbor any doubts about the quality and reliability of Windham rifles, you must check out the torture test performed on a Windham rifle by LegallyArmedAmerica channel on youtube. You’ll probably go out and buy one after viewing.

  4. I opted for the SRC in the 7.62×39 since I already had two AKs and found brass ammo at 300 bucks for 1120 rounds, no other difference and I can hook up the Windham .223/5.56 upper for a tad over 500. Smooth as butter with twice the knockdown power.. I carried an M-14 in RVN and just could not give up that big bore kick.. Wish I’d kept my old Bushmaster though.

  5. I purchased a windham SRC from a sporting goods store in Ohio for $599.00, free shipping. I’m new to the AR family, but I think this is one of the best buys available on the market today. Wally World sells the same rifle where I live for $850.00, so I think I got a “GREAT” deal on mine. It goes bang every time I shoot it, and it’s accuracy if plenty good enough for me. I play with a Bushnell Red Dot at 25 yards and shooting clover leaf groups. Mostly getting 1 inch groups at 100 yards with my Nikon P-223 4×12 scope. I’ve mad a few changes, fore end from ebay, steel flip up iron sights that co-witness with my red dot perfectly. So for all the Nay Sayers, screw them. If you like the Windham Rifle buy it, I don’t think you’ll regret it. Love mine, and will never part with it.

  6. Put several 100 rounds through the Windham AR 15 SRC with exceptional results. In terms of value for performance, it is a fine rifle. You can argue that there is a lot of difference in performance of ARs along price lines, but with the stock US companies, I really don’t see a lot of difference. Windham has a good story and I like the fact that buying one supports entrepreneurial pioneers and jobs in small town America. As for the accuracy of the Windham, 99% of the guns are better than the guy shooting it. This one fills the bill. Windham also makes it easy to order parts and has a good array on their simple website. Needed a 5 round magazine for mine and it arrived in just a few days from Windham direct. Plus, it’s their mag so I knew it would work when I ordered it. Its a fine rifle and I like what it stands for.

  7. I just bought the WWSRC for $700 even and added a 3×9 red/green variable scope for $120. I’m in California so it has a bullet button and 10 round mag. I was at the Wild West gun show and held several AR’s before deciding on the WW. It just felt like it wanted to be mine. I liked the light weight of the gun and the scope was really cool. I’m ex Navy and have been more of a pistol man, but I’ve always wanted an AR and at that price point I just couldn’t say no. I’m eager to pick it up and go shoot it!

  8. Bought my windham about a year ago little over $700 did a lot of research for my money , shoots anything got 8 mags 3×9 variable scope red/ green mil spec
    Love it

  9. Some people show their ignorance by their posts. So dismiss them for what they are. I do my own reloading, where you learn a lot about twist rates and what is tuned for a particular rifle. I brought a 6 inch grouping at 100 yards down to 1/2 inch moa with my loads. So usually the gun is not the problem 😉

  10. I will not say that any AR platform is better than any other simply based on price. I, being a veteran myself, really love that Windham does what it does. Supporting the troops and its loyalty to its employees and customers. I have recently purchased the WWSRC and love it. I like the fact that there were no sights, as I want to put on my own custom sights. By the way, you can purchase a Windham with sights! At the range I put on a scope and sighted in with 3 rounds at 200yds. After that I was shooting 1.5in groups all day with 62gr 5.56 rounds. I did try out a couple mags of .223 55gr and still found those to be quite accurate given the drop in weight. .223 rounds were still grouping at 2.5 inches at 200yds for me. I will say that there is one thing I do not care for with the Windham however, and that is it seems to be a bit on the over gassed side and launches the extracted rounds way to far. There is nothing like apologizing to the guy 3 benches down every time you smack him in the face with a nice fresh hot casing.

  11. There are more expensive AR platforms one can purchase, but not necessarily better ones. The WW SRC maybe an entry level AR to some, but its the perfect weapon for the non-professional, home defender, or prepper who needs a quality long rifle, on a budget. And if the user should decide to do so, the SRC is upgradeable.

  12. I’ve always been a handgun and shotgun fan, but find myself drawn to an entry level AR due to personal budget constraints {…FURLOUGH due to sequestration}. I’m hoping to eventually wind up with an AR that can serve as both close quarter needs as well as open range use. I’ve been surfing and ‘window shopping’ to try to preplan my actions. My desired end result will be a NONcomposite AR with both iron sights for close quarters as well as raised, see thru mounts and holographic and magnifier for long range use. I’m hoping that EDH will respond with some guidance from his experience and expertise, but am open to any and all suggestions.

    Proud Veteran of Two Veteran Sons…Proud to Support OUR 2nd Amendment Rights

  13. I purchased a WW SRC AR15 and my friend purchased a Colt AR15. In my opinion, my weapon has a better finish and outside of that, there is absolutely no difference in the two rifles – shooting, accuracy, etc. And at $300+ less than he paid, I got the better deal.

  14. My 2 cents worth on the WW SRC. I do believe it is the best AR for the price out there. You can certainly make the argument that the Colt is a better AR (and you are probably right) but you are also paying for it. If around $1300 is your price point then go for it. At an $800 price point the WW is dam close.
    Over 95% of the guys and gals at WW used to build the Bushmaster. The AR’s that they are building now as a new independent privately owned company is superior to the Bushmaster.
    I see a couple people wining about “selling a gun with no sights”, well that’s the point of the SRC (Site Ready Carbine). Most people (including myself) like to personalize the sighting the way they like it and end up swapping out the stock configuration anyway.
    One other thing, the comment “It doesn’t even have the proper twist rate!” The SRC’s 1:7 twist is designed for the lighter weight .223 bullets that most of us use. If you are having problems with Zombies or are getting geared up for Al-Qaida then you are going to want the 1:9 twist for the heavier bullets.

  15. I bought one today from Tri-State, price was $919.99 so seems like things are going up. Haven’t even shot it yet but nothing but good things from the sales guy as well as all the internet sites I’ve found. I have a S&W M&P15 that works great, and this one seems similar in every way. Hoping the Windham is a little more accurate as I wanted it for hunting song dogs. The Smith does ok but about 2 moa, hopefully I can get closer to 1moa in a carbine-sized setup.

  16. I bought the Windham MPC with carry handle and front and rear sights,1 mag,case,and sling for a whopping $797.00. It is very accurate,feeds any kind of ammo,and meets the eye test for quality. We’ve shot it side by side with my brother in laws Daniel Defense and it matched it step for step.

    I cant say what the “best” AR is but if you purchase a Windham,you will be pleased with your new rifle. There are plenty of other manufacturers that make great rifles as well. The main thing is get one,shoot it often ,and fight for our 2nd ammendment rights

  17. I agree with Crowe Rock River Arms seems to be the best of the mid priced AR platforms out there. Sure you could spend a lot more but no need. Just purchased an RRA LAR Elite Comp model 1270 flat top which comes with RRA flip front sight,A.R.M.S. #40 low-profile rear sight,1:9 chrome lined 16″ barrel, RRA tactical muzzle brake, 2 stage trigger with winter trigger guard (if you are a cold weather shooter this is key)and a half quad free float hand guard so you are not holding onto a cheese grater but can hang all the furniture you may need. MSRP $1445 but you can get if for just about $1000 brand new if you shop smart. Check out this link for complete details

  18. I have a hbc made by them,and i think its a great rifle for the price,shoots good and works everytime.i’m not a rich guy and can’t afford $5,000 for a rifle and scope comb,just a old cripled up vietnam vet,who still loves to go shoot. my other AR is a Colt sp-1,i got over 30 years ago,and i don’t know how many rounds i’ve shot with it,more than a’ve shot white tail deer with it at 100 to 600 yeads,mostly head shots,still a great rifle.i got this new rifle from a guy who lost his job,he had to sell it to feed his kids,thats sad.i got the rifle,a slide-fire stock and a 1000 rounds of 5.56 ss109 ammo for a 1000 bucks,a good deal.i was able to help him and got a great rifle.p.s. i love to shoot it on full auto.

  19. It’s inexpensive, so it can’t be any good ? Love the sentiment. I bought one of these as wallyworld for $799.00 it’s my 6th or 7th ar. I like the fit better than most of my others. THIS IS A FINE WEAPON. There is no “for the money” comment either, just a fine weapon. This is probably the best ar value out there. I’ve owned BM, Olympic, Colt HB and SP-1, etc…

  20. “The low price point guns are aimed at the new buyer. Why not sell them a gun you can shoot out of the box without spending any more except for ammo?”

    The MPC would be that Windham. MSRP is only $45 higher than the SRC. Clearly, a noob should be buying a weapon with sights.

  21. Any time Irish-7. I’ve been on plenty of forums where the holier than thou set can ruin a civil conversation.

    Be safe, consider the source and shoot it ike you stole it!

  22. If you’re going to run a scope on an AR then no rear sight is fine. No front sight is fine. I’m looking at the new guy on the block. He may not have the knowledge or the cash for an EOTech or Aimpoint. The low price point guns are aimed at the new buyer. Why not sell them a gun you can shoot out of the box without spending any more except for ammo?

    Plus, I’m tired of watching lame low budget Scy Fy movies where the “military” or “SWAT” have no rear sights as they get gunned down.

  23. Thanks for the detailed explanation, EdH! I have the utmost respect for those educated folks that can post without flying off the handle in anger, or turning the blog into a self-absorbed dialog. I am ready to drop out of the conversation on “Four Guns Every Shooter Should Own” because of the Holier Than Thou Know It All’s have joined the discussion. I wish you all the best in your business! I was an Armorer for a few years early in my military career, so I know a little about rebuilding and replacing parts on rifles and machine guns. Although I was not on a budget, I did research costs for ordering weapons parts. In the back of the manuals, there was an SMR (Supply, Maintenance & Recoverability code). This dictated where the part came from, the level of maintenance authorized to replace the part and whether or not the piece could be fixed instead of replaced. Also, if there was a requirement to turn the part in (or just discard it). In some cases, it was more economical to order the next higher assembly, as opposed to rebuilding / replacing multiple pieces. The extractor on an M2 HB CAL.50 Machine Gun is one part that comes to mind. Anyway, even though I was not personally profiting from frugal practices, I did my best to save Uncle Sam money. This was during the period where the government was paying $600.00 for toilet seats. I recall the price of M2 HB CAL.50 MG barrels going from $290.00 to $744.00 in 10 years, from 1986 to 1996. I don’t want to ramble. Thanks again for keeping it civil.

  24. Guys, the complaints about no sights miss the point. This is one model that is sold as a flat top. That’s the way I bought it and I did so because I wanted the picatinny rails. Check out their line. If you want sights, they’ve got ’em. I love my Windham (with an Aimpoint T-1), and I’d buy it again tomorrow.

  25. The DPMS Recon Tactical is the finest AR15 for the money. I got it for less than $1k from my local gun shop brand new (with full rails, flip up sights, 2 PMAGS, case, CAR Operator stock). Smoothest action I’ve ever felt. It shoots like a .22 and fires 5.56. There’s a reason why there’s a 9-month waiting list to get one! It’s a steal if you can get your hands on one.

    Iraq War Vet
    Armored Recon
    1CAV, US Army

  26. I have the HBC variant. Absolutely love it. I wish I could post the pics of my targets from last week’s trip to the range. It is a tack driver.

  27. @ Irish-7. When I build a rifle I have to account for every dollar spent on every part/kit to be included in the price of the gun. I also have to account for the time I put in to building/assembling the rifle. It is no different for the bigger gun makers. They also have to account for their overhead. Bigger companies/vendors buy in bulk and sell their product at different tiers. They can sell to someone like me at a price discounted from retail because I will buy in bulk but in a smaller bulk then my vendors. They have to cover overhead and still have room for profit. No one getting in to business is in it to lose money. Then there is the retail buyer who buys from store fronts (physical/internet) or at shows. You always see similar prices from most everyone whether they are the bigger guys or smaller ones. Yes, that means the bigger guys have more profit at the register but they also have to pay more overhead so the actual profit is about the same.

    When I build a rifle I include things that the bigger guys don’t and maybe leave out something that the big guys supply. I include two mags, a rear sight and a basic sling where the big guys will have a plastic shell case, one mag and a sling or another configuration. If I have to ship a gun to another state I have to account not only for the postage but also for the packaging. That is where you get the Shipping & “Handling” charges passed on to the customer. Don’t forget transfer/background fees and state sales tax where applicable. It is all has to be accounted for.

    When it comes down to it, parts, time and services are money. You sell a gun for the most you can get for it but at a reasonable enough price to where you don’t price yourself out of competition. Cutting one piece over another or including one piece and not another is a way to stay competitive at a reasonable price and supply what you think the buyer wants.

    I built my personal rifle and AR pistol. In doing that I got to choose what sights I wanted. I have specific needs in that area because I use them at my full time profession. Others who posted also like to choose their own. Some people don’t have the knowledge or experience and are getting in at the best price for a gun you can load up, sight in and and go to town with. They learn as they progress.

  28. Well, the gun maker should not be charging any more for something that is part of the actual weapon. To me, that’s like selling the gun without a magazine. Sure, it will fire. But, the equipment is not operating at its optimum capacity. I agree that 100 bucks is way too much for the few small pieces that make up the front sight post and rear sight aperture.

  29. I found my SRC in my local Wal-mart and love it. Only put a couple hundred rounds through it 55gr .223 and 62gr 5.56 but it handles them both just fine.

    I would rather choose my own sights then get stuck with what the manufacturer puts on it and charges me an extra $100 or more.

  30. I concur with the guy who complained about selling a gun with no sights. That is like selling a car with no windshield. Sure, you can still drive it, but seeing where you are going can be a problem in wind, rain, snow or bugs. I have NcSTAR scopes for my Bushmaster M4 and Ruger Mini-14. They were great deals at about a hundred bucks. So, if I found a Windham for $720.00, then got the exact same scope deal, we are talking about spending a little over $800.00 for an Assault Rifle. Is that really a bargain? When I was an Army Supply Sergeant in the mid 1990’s, the government was buying the Colt M16A1 Rifle for $460.00. Granted, inflation has increased the prices of everything over the years. I guess my point is, to call any .223/5.56mm rifle a bargain, for me it would have to be less than $800.00 total cost. I think my next rifle will be another Mini-14.

  31. Twist rate, metal cased ammo, ho hum yada yada. Using cheap Wolf 55gr, the Windham easily grouped 1.5 ” @ 100 yards with a BSA 6-24×40 scope. Bottom line is performance, and i am happy with it. Shoot a gun before you diss it.

  32. Right on! My local Walmart carrys the Windhams. It did not take me long to see that it was clearly the best buy for the money out of all the ARs they carried. Fit, finish and function is superb. Gas block is pinned on; not a set screw job. My nephew just bought a Bushmaster on Black Friday, and I have to tell you, the Windham is far better quality; that much is visible to the naked eye just in terms of fit and finsh. I believe and hope that Windham Weaponry has a great future ahead.

  33. I purchased the Windham HBC ($869,) recently. I have put about a 1000 rnds of PMC 223 thru it and it is a work horse. I purchased extra magpul mags and they also work well. No hangups, misfires, misfeeds. On a scale of 1 to 10 my weapon is a 10+. Looking into now purchasing a Windham HBC flat top so I can install a scope, green dot laser and light. This new one will shoot strictly 5.56, 62gr hpbt. Excellent guns.

  34. I know these are A LOT more expensive than Windham, but Larue, LMT, Hogan, LWRC, Noveske etc shoot like nothing else. There are many others, but these are the ones that I could think of off the top of my head.

  35. I have had shot several different brands. Like has been said previously there are over 100. Most forged AR’s are all similar in my opinion, just have different brand machined on. My favorite, best made, and shooting AR that I own is Black Rain Ordinance. Machined upper and lower, and nickel boron coated bolt cycles great. There is no need for any accu wedge due to built-in upper lower adjustment. Build your own is my preferred method. I am not a fanboy for any brand really, just bought black Rain Ordinance to try machined upper and lower and its great. Who’s to say what the best is?

  36. the people at windham weaponry are the key to having a good experience when needing someone to help with technical assistance or gunsmithing or anything a.r.I bought two bushmasters when they were still in Windham Maine,before the Remington thing,and they were great to deal with back then,but when the were absorbed by Remington that all went out the its nice to be able to go back to the same experienced,efficient,congenial people that were there before.

  37. Actually warranties are for products with defects. It happens. Looking for information about Windham earlier this year I found all positive info with many raves. Two had disclaimers that the review was on the second rifle sent them. The first had glitches. (One review had torture test in the site name not sure of the other.) They both liked the weapon and greatly appreciated the customer service. For me its a good entry lvl rifle and I agree that if it won’t cycle all ammo there’s something wrong somewhere.

  38. If your gun can’t cycle steel-cased rounds, it needs work. Mine will reliably fire whatever I feed it and I wouldn’t have it any other way. Warranties are for those that don’t know how their weapon functions.

  39. I own a Bushmaster M4A2 Patrolman. But, I have handled several variations of Windham models at different gun stores in Texas. Windham Weaponry AR’s appear to be well made and they stand behind their product. They sell at Wal-Mart for $579.00, plus tax. This is a bare bones model, of course. The Bushmaster was $1K, plus tax. Seems you can do a lot of upgrades and “tricking out” the Windham for the $400.00 difference in price? Just a thought. And, if you do not care for a Windham, that is why there are so many other competitors to chose from. Find what YOU like and then go buy it!

  40. I bought one when they came out because they support the troops, came from “Old Bushmaster”, and have an American Flag laser etched on the lower. What more can you ask for? Oh, wait… a good gun.

  41. I’m with Matt C. I’ll build my own. I also build for others. Yes I have a type 7 FFL. Every manufacturer has its fanboys. That is good for them. I believe they are missing out on a lot of good products. Wyndham makes a good product. “The Best” is about opinions. I know the best for me and what I’ll use it for. Wyndham, Bushmaster, BCM, Del Ton, Colt, Anderson and many others would work for me too. I don’t see a “BEST” and think anyone who claims one over another is too narrow-minded to get it.

    Articles like this do nothing but cause arguments and spur dissent. Some People wear their opinions on their sleeve like their feelings and are in for much butt-hurt.

  42. You just gotta love the big-name-AR fanboys here who have developed an inferior complex when a brand of rifle comes along. They who throw a quick comment out of “its not a so-and-so brand” or “its never going to be as good as a so-and-so brand” and give ZERO details to support their “expert opinions” and just run away. Butt-hurt fanboys are a funny crowd. The quality with this brand is probably as good or better than the big-brands out there. The “big-brands” whose QUALITY HAS BEEN FALLING FAST in recent times by the way. LOL.

  43. I bought a Windham Weaponry SRC and love it! Its a great coyote gun and I find it to be very accurate and reliable. I put a Nikon P223 scope with BDC 600 and sighted it in at 100 yards. With the bullet drop compensator scope I was within 1 and a half inches of the bulls eye at 200 yards. Not bad for an old man of 62. But its not me, its the gun that is so accurate. It groups shots very tightly.

  44. This is a privately owned company. All made in America by Americans. Everything is properly staked!! This gun is a piece of art… I would put this up against any ar. Do yourself a favor go buy one !!! I’m buying my 2nd Windham next week.

  45. I bought two Windham AR’s through a group buy while in Afghanistan. Best end of the world gun for the money. Bought a CDI and an MPC. The CDI came fully tricked out with Magpul gear, but still came with a crappy standard aluminum magazine. Figured they would’ve thrown in a PMAG.

    Gun zeroed right out of the box at 25M, it’s been a nail driver ever since. Not sure I would but any other name brand AR, except Larue if I had the cash.

  46. I have had several AR platform rifles from the “Top” brands and the Windham SRC that I gave $720 for rates as well as any of the others to me. The quality for the price is outstanding, extremely well put together. I have run a couple of thousand rounds through this one without a single FTF or other malfunction. The SRC model comes with the standard AR front sight and Diamond Head rear pop-up sight. I could not be happier unless it had a M203 mounted and just ordered another SRC for my family. Not only am I happy with the rifles I am also happy with the Windham story and like the idea of helping a “small town” American company!

  47. Great another overgassed gun with crappy springs and buffer that is to light. There are other rifles that are a better value for the dollar.

  48. With over 100 AR manufacturers on the market at various levels Wyndham has a lot of competition. You can order stripped receivers and with a little knowledge piece together an AR using video from YouTube and various AR websites. The weapon you build will be of the same quality and come in up to $200 less then the Wyndham. Plus, you’ll have sights and two 30 round mags. For someone just getting in to the AR scene, with no knowledge other then knowing how to work the gun, the Wyndham is a good option and gets the job done. The “optics ready” guns are great and inexpensive but a serviceable red dot is going to run about another $300 +/- and flip up sights will grab you for **no less** then $150. And you can’t run a polymer flip up sight on the gas block if you plan on putting more then 100 rounds through the rifle in a trip to the range.

    “Sights: None” is what bothers me most. Most AR guys will end up with a couple dozen aluminum mags and can get them with the no-tilt followers fairly cheap. But, It bugs the heck out of me that manufacturers sell their carbines with nothing to aim through but your good or bad intentions. The put a railed gas block on the bugger how about just pitting a front sight on instead. That gets us half way there. Another $60 for a Magpul BUS or even less for a UTG or NCSTAR Match clone and you’re in business.

    Yes, Wyndham makes a quality product. It is a good entry level gun. No, they aren’t the best bang for the buck and I believe they are a little over priced based on the retail tags I’ve seen on them and comparable guns at store fronts.

  49. Excellent rifle ~ I have about a thousand rounds through mine so far and LOVE IT! Fit and finish is excellent got mine for right around $750 money well spent. Considering their varmint model for my next AR!

  50. I picked up a Windhim rifle MPC model with the American flag on it. This was my first AR rifle and I am very happy with it. I’ve put about 500 rounds through it, a mix of brass and steel case and it runs flawlessly. Granted, there are higher end ARs out there on the market, but this rifle suits me just fine. I looked at other brands but went with WW because of what the owner did to bring manufacturing jobs back to his town and employee people. I am thankful to have been able to support wounded soldiers with my purchase and a business that is putting Americans back to work. I was also fortunate enough to pick up a Bushmaster Patrolman’s Carbine, as partial payment on an old truck, a few months after buying the Windhim; both are nice but WW has my loyalty.

  51. Considering I’ve fired both and have read reports on both the AR and AK’s. AK 47’s still win out over any AR’s in cost, ammo, parts and most of all reliability under harsh conditions.

  52. If you are looking for a great value I would purchase a Barnes Precision. They are a up and coming US manufacture that makes a high quality AR for 2/3 the price of the competition. I have toured the manufacture and they are the real deal.

    Don’t be cheap… buy brass. The gun warranty cards strictly state “DO NOT FIRE STEEL CASED AMMO THROUGH THIS WEAPON. IT WILL VOID YOUR WARRANTY!”. Duh.
    I have a Windhham and it’s a great gun. Purchased mine with a flat top and MAGPUL flip sights for $850 at a gun show. This weapon also comes with a chrome lined barrel. I have over 2000 rounds of Federal brass through it and never had one FTF or any other issues with it. It’s tight all around and built just as good as any Stag arms, Bushy, or Colt. I just picked up a brand new Colt M4 which only has a chromoly barrel… spent $1300 and can’t tell the difference. The Windham came with a nicer trigger from factory but all of my AR’s get a Timney within 2-3 days of purchase anyway. I mostly love the Windham story… great American owner and great business values! Good Job Windham Weaponry!!!

  54. My S&W M&P 15 has a 1:8 twist so I can use 79 grain DRT ammo. Of course it will fire lighter rounds at the range too and is a tack driver. The tolerances are so good I couldn’t get an Accuwedge in, even after much shaving of the wedge.

    Oh, and some advice to “whapo)……NEVER USE TULA STEEL AMMO IN ANY GUN YOU LOVE (or even like). There’s plenty of cheap brass ammo out there for range use from folks like CTD or Bulk Ammo.

  55. Have a Windham. Disappointed thus far.

    Will not feed some rounds, Tula steel case…even Remington 45 gr brass. 55 gr Remington brass worked fine.

    Did a side by side with the Windham ($771), Stag Model 3 ($760), Del-Ton TRX ($1100), and the Windham was by far the poorest performer. The others had no problems with ANY ammo.

    Customer service has been responsive. We’ll see if I have a lemon or what.

    Right now, at this price point, I find the Stag to be far superior. The Del-Ton is more expensive and a very fine weapon.

  56. So for all you guys out there that know about these guns, would this be a good starting point or spend a little more
    And get something better or is the windham a good start?

  57. Remember that 55-gr. M193 round was being fired from a 20″ M-16 with 1:12 twist. It’s not going to do the same thing from a 16″ 1:9.

  58. I thought Windham Weaponry merged with POF USA & moved to Arizona… Is this true & if so, that can only help them in r&d because of POF’s high end designs. Windham is in the lower & middle priced AR spectrum as POF is in the higher priced designed AR’s.

  59. As for myself, I know that the Windham is built by, and on the machinery of, the personnel of Bushmaster. Fine weapon, heard nothing but good about them. I just want fluffy clouds and unicorns, I want a decent AR/M4 for around $600. I want an accurate, reliable 5.56 for drilling blue helmets. Windham is nice, but I don’t have the money.

  60. I have a windham and I got one around the time they first came out. I love it. It shoots great with 55 grain pmc bronze. The gas key and caste nut were properly staked. The bolt is your standard mil spec bolt. When i bought mine I got mine for $699 at one of the local gun shows. I have about 1000 rds through it. Dont have time to shoot as much as I would like.

  61. If you’re gonna spend a grand, spend $1300 and get the superb Stag 3G. For the extra 3 hundo, you get an 18″ fluted stainless bbl, brake, sleek 15″ Samson hand guard and the awesome Gieselle S3G trigger.
    To make those upgrades to the Windham would cost you way more than $300 bucks.

  62. So, was the gas key properly staked? Was the castle nut properly staked? What’s the BCG material?

    Looks good, interested in how one of these stacks up against a colt LE6920.

    1. Yes, everything was properly staked . The BGC is constructed from Carpenter 158 Steel – MP/HP Tested.

      ~ Dave Dolbee

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your discussions, feedback and comments are welcome here as long as they are relevant and insightful. Please be respectful of others. We reserve the right to edit as appropriate, delete profane, harassing, abusive and spam comments or posts, and block repeat offenders. All comments are held for moderation and will appear after approval.