Guest post by Jonathan Owen, CEO of SHWAT.com
Hearing Protection isn’t sexy. Of course neither is your ears ringing or having to ask “what?” “WHAT?” Soldiers, hunters, competitive shooters—all have hearing damage among their ranks. When shooting and hunting, most of us try to mitigate that as much as possible, but using hearing protection can come at the cost of situational awareness. For a hunter, this could compromise communication with others, and even cause you to flat miss an opportunity. Technology has brought us a long way, and one product I’ve seen improve over the past four years is the Etymotic Research ER125-GSP15BN GunsSport Pro series High-Definition Electronic Earplugs. They have their limitations, but they are better than when I first saw them and they solve some real-world problems. I’ll address real-world concerns and an urban legend about adequate hearing protection or “ear pro.”
Speaking of the so called real world, it gives us plenty of reasons to despise the various incarnations of hearing protection or “ear pro.” Foam plugs can be really effective at blocking everything. As a hunter, I don’t want to block everything. Even when shooting targets, I want to communicate with my shooting buddies. Getting plugs properly inserted can be a pain and leave you unprotected.
Let’s say you wear ear muffs. In the summer they get hot in a hurry. No joy. Want that perfect cheek weld and eye relief on your precision rifle? Odds are your muffs will interfere. Don’t forget about the other “pro” we know we should use—eye protection, yet the temples of your glasses can break the seal of the muffs to your ear, marginalizing their effectiveness. To be fair, muffs can help keep you and your ears warm when it’s cold, but that doesn’t mitigate the rest of the problems. Ditch the muffs and don a beanie and you’re warmer anyway. Ever tried to cram muffs on under a helmet, even a really great one like a Team Wendy helmet? Marginally doable, but no fun for sure.
Read all that and you might conclude I’m anti-ear muffs, but in fact I love my Howard Leight Impact Sport electronic muffs. I started wearing them after my ears started ringing. I’d used hearing pro almost religiously for years, but when tactical hog hunting, I started using the big-name silicone ear pro that was supposed to work off mitigating sound pressure through a small open tunnel. I don’t know if they are a complete farce, or if mine didn’t fit quite right or what, but I wish I’d never bought them.
In addition to being more effective at decibel reduction, my electronic muffs amplify ambient sounds like whispers, hogs munching on farmer’s wheat, etc., but when a loud spike of sound hits (BANG!), they block it. But as muffs, they do all that good stuff with all the drawbacks mentioned before. So, wouldn’t the ultimate solution be the same technology but tinier, fitted into my ear canal?
I first tried out that concept as build by Etymotic in 2011 at the first-ever Silencers Are Legal Shoot in Dallas. Odd, you think? Not really. Silencers are phenomenal, but there are far too many variables to simply assume you’ll never need hearing protection once you’ve bought a suppressor. That’s a topic for another day, but you don’t need a $200 tax stamp to own Etymotic Gun Sport Pros, and as far as I can tell they are legal in all 50 states.
In 2011, the Gun Sport Pro (GSP) plugs seemed like a good idea, but they struck me as awkward. The newest iteration has a greatly improved form factor.
Etymotic Gun Sport Pro electronic earplugs operate in two modes, selectable by a tiny throw lever. In “Lo” mode, you basically get normal levels of audio fed to your ears until some sound exceeds safe levels. Etymotic says that continuous loud noise is automatically reduced by 15%. Outdoors, this mode nicely worked while I was getting in some long-range practice, including shooting .338 Lapua Magnum.
The “High” mode works like my Howard Leights, amplifying soft sounds and conversational speech. Unlike the familiar Impact Sports seen at every shooting event I’ve been to, there’s no volume adjustment, but I didn’t miss that feature either. This is a great mode to hunt with.
In both modes you get what Etymotic calls “High Definition” sound with 40 Hz-16 kHz bandwidth. A host of high-tech, high-end miniaturized electronics makes this possible. Specs aside, the sound quality is really good.
A surprise was the variety pack of accessories that came with the electronic earplugs. The GSP has replaceable filters to deal with pesky things like ear wax and other debris build up. That’s a testament to the level of development, but the fact that they ship replacement filters with the GSP adds to the value. A plethora of eartips are included to fit your own ears.
Now, to take on an urban legend. I asked Etymotic’s Director of Audiology Patty Johnson, Au.D., a couple of questions many shooters hold as gospel:
SHWAT: Is it true that to have proper hearing protection, a shooter must use muffs to insulate skeletal bones that transmit sound to the inner ear?
Doctor Johnson: If a person had an inner ear (with a cochlea, hair cells and nerve fibers that transmit sound to the brain) but no middle or external ear (no ear canal, eardrum, or middle ear) they could still hear if sounds were loud enough to vibrate the skull bones. There are genetic disorders that result in no outer or middle ear, and those people are fit with bone-conduction hearing aids. A little vibrator is worn on the head, which vibrates the skull so the person can hear.
When the outer or middle ear prevents someone from hearing, we call it a conductive hearing loss. The maximum conductive hearing loss (if there’s no outer or middle ear) is 60 dB. Therefore if you had a PERFECT earplug/hearing protector, the maximum amount of sound reduction it could provide would be 60 dB.
With a blast such as gunfire or an explosion, the pressure wave (and sound is pressure) hits the whole body, including the skull. This vibration moves through the inner ear and is heard as sound. It’s not at all unusual for gunfire to be around 160 dB. So even if a person had a maximum conductive loss, 100 dB of that 160 dB blast would still reach the inner ear. In order to prevent that, you’d have to shield the entire body.
SHWAT: So there are limits to how much sound a hearing protector can provide?
Doctor Johnson: When maximum attenuation is needed, the way we achieve that is to wear earmuffs over earplugs, but there’s a limit to how much additional protection this provides. Surprisingly, it’s about 5 dB on average. So if a person wore earplugs that provide 20 dB of protection, and wore earmuffs over that, the total protection would be about 25 dB. For those working in extremely high-noise areas where maximum protection is necessary (such as the flight deck of an aircraft carrier), deeply seated foam earplugs are used, along with heavy-duty earmuffs, and they still need to limit exposure duration to reduce their risk of noise-induced hearing loss.
SHWAT: So what’s the takeaway?
Doctor Johnson: Wearing earmuffs when shooting doesn’t protect more than earplugs. The key for either protector is to get a good fit. In some instances earmuffs are worse than earplugs when shooting because the pressure blast can knock the muff away from the ear, breaking the seal to the head and resulting in little actual protection.
I wish I could say the Gun Sport Pros were perfect, but they aren’t. The Achilles tendon is the battery. The tiny battery in each device should last about ten days, which is actually reasonable, considering its diminutive size.
The batteries’ small size also made my first outing with the GSPs an adventure. I’d placed the batteries in the devices but left the battery tray/door open, per the instructions, to leave them “off.” There’s no power switch. However, when I opened the little carrying case at the King’s Arsenal private outdoor range, one of the batteries must have fallen out.
To answer the obvious question, yes, with no battery (or a dead one) these effectively function as ear plugs. I didn’t bring extra batteries, so that was a real bummer. Nobody likes messing with batteries, but that’s simply part of owning these high-end electronic earplugs.
Some have noted the Gun Sport Pros are insufficient for indoor-range shooting, and I don’t doubt it. When outdoors, standing in the direct line of blast from an aggressive muzzle brake on a 5.56 AR-15, I had to reach for my muffs to wear on top of the Etymotics. On the other hand, at an indoor range shooting .22s to qualify for my NRA Instructor rating, they were perfect in the Normal mode.
While I’ve only had these a few weeks, I have to say that in my quest for excellent hearing protection that doesn’t adversely impact my hunting, I’m pretty pleased with these. They are comfortable, effective at blocking what I want blocked and amplifying what I want to hear. As of now, they are my first choice in hearing protection.
But they are pricey, $299. Still, if they stop ringing ears and offer better communication on the line or in the field, they’re a real bargain.
Jonathan Owen, CEO of Special Hog Weapons and Tactics, started pulling triggers in the 4-H Shooting Sports program. Soon, he was teaching air-rifle marksmanship and gun safety. His introduction to hunting after college was frozen season of absentee deer, leading him to conclude he was a shooter, not a hunter. That led to a civilian fascination with all things tactical. Later, when introduced to the dynamic world of tactical hog hunting, all that changed and Special Hog Weapons and Tactics was born. Today, Owen is a highly regarded industry professional who loves both the shooting and hunting aspects of the firearms community. A writer, photographer, videographer, storyteller and consultant, he loves bringing new experiences and gear to anyone who’ll pay attention. This material is adapted from Special Hog Weapons And Tactics. Copyright ©2015 SHWAT.com.