Ammunition

SIG SAUER Scorpion – Modern Battle Pistol with a Sting

SIG SAUER’s new Scorpion handgun takes the 1911 pistol a notch higher in performance and brings proven combat ability into the new century. The Scorpion is a far different pistol than the blue steel and walnut 1911 handguns many of us deployed in the past. The SIG looks different, performs differently and leaves little to be desired. It is definitely a 1911 to the marrow. The new SIG features a rugged corrosion and wear-resistant Cerakote finish. Cerakote is a proven ceramic finish that is low maintenance, resists wear and requires little lubrication.

SIG Scorpion Features

Gun metal gray SIG SAUER Scorpion on a brown/black/gray stone background.
The SIG Scorpion is arguably the finest tactical pistol on the planet for the price. You could spend more money and not find anything appreciably better.

From pencil scratch testing to extreme salt spray testing, Cerakote has proven stable in long exposure to the elements. Heat tests did not damaged the finish up to 500 degrees. Along with other modern features, the Scorpion integrates a light rail into the dust cover. Coupled with self-luminous iron sights (night sights) with tritium inserts, the pistol is well-appointed for use around the clock.

There are many features inherent in the design, a confluence of the best of SIG and 1911. Legendary SIG quality control, and the 1911’s combat proven design, is a good combination. There are several versions of the Scorpion, including both 4.25- and 5-inch barrel variants. The shorter length was chosen for this review.

The pistol features what is often referred to as the Commander length barrel and slide with standard barrel bushing. The fit of the barrel to the slide, the barrel to the barrel bushing, and the locking lugs to the slide are excellent. Going to a shorter barrel length requires the pistol use a bushingless lockup without the barrel bushing. This is required of the shorter pistol to accommodate the more severe barrel tilt necessary for a short barrel 1911.

While a number of 4-inch barrel 1911 handguns have exhibited excellent reliability, the consensus is the Commander length, with a 4.25-inch barrel and shortened barrel bushing is the more reliable system. The barrel lugs fit into the slide mortise smoothly and snugly. Tight tolerances mean superior accuracy. Good fitting means less eccentric wear in the long run.

The pistol is fitted with a set of grips designed by Hogue and termed Piranha grips. These grips are an interesting experience for one used to walnut or rubber. They offer a comfortable yet abrasive grip in a groundbreaking design. The grips and the nicely checkered front strap make for excellent adhesion. Despite aggressive checkering, the grip is not uncomfortable when firing full power loads and the pistol does not slip in the hand. Bottom line—there is nothing better in the handgun world for adhesion and control than this combination.

SIG SAUER Scorpion with focus on gray checkered frontstrap on medium blue background.
The checkered frontstrap of the Scorpion makes for excellent adhesion.

The pistol features an extended magazine well and a mainspring housing that fits the hand well. Although you may seldom need to perform a speed reload in a defensive situation, the option must be left open, and you should practice speed reloads. You will practice often and practice hard if you are serious about personal defense.

The extended magazine well makes rapid ammunition replenishment much more efficient. Training will go smoother and as confidence in repeatable ability builds, so does combat proficiency. The single greatest shortcoming of students in my training classes is a lack of familiarity with the handgun. Be familiar with the pistol.

The dust cover features an integral MIL STD 1913 rail for mounting combat lights or laser devices. The slide lock safety is an ambidextrous unit. The slide lock safety bucks the trend as the levers are actually smaller than the norm rather than the common extended type. The safety is crisp and indents in a positive manner. After use and evaluation, we find the size is no drawback for rapid manipulation and avoids snagging the lever on the holster or garments when drawing from concealed carry. The upswept grip safety is a good design; well executed.

Silver Scorpion with a short guide rod, barrell pointing down and to the left on a medium blue background
The Scorpion does not use a full length guide rod, making for simple maintenance.

The grip safety is the popular beavertail design with memory groove. The beavertail safety helps lead the hand into the proper firing grip on the draw. The beavertail releases its hold on the safety properly about halfway into its travel. The memory groove is an asset for those of us that use the thumbs forward, two hand firing grip. Often this grip, while very stable and accuracy enhancing, causes the palm to rise off of the beavertail. The memory groove beavertail safety helps in this regard. After looking over these features and handling the pistol, the first impression of the Scorpion is this is a service pistol without compromise. Further evaluation and testing did not contradict this early impression.

The low-profile low-drag sights give you an excellent sight picture. The tritium inserts are bright and the three dot configuration lets you quickly acquire the sight picture. Self luminous iron sights are required of a pistol used for 24-hour personal defense. The slide design is different from traditional 1911 handguns, with a slightly squared profile. This is a subtle change to give the SIG 1911 an appearance similar to the SIG P series handguns. When ordering a holster, do not simply specify 4.25-inch Commander length 1911 with rail—be certain you specify that the pistol is a SIG 1911 as the slide profile differs.

While a distinctive handgun, the SIG Scorpion has the best features of the 1911 design. A straight-to-the-rear trigger compression, low bore axis with little leverage for the muzzle to rise in recoil, and a well-designed grip frame add up to a capable handgun. The SIG features a modern external extractor. While a properly fitted tool steel extractor of the original type is perfectly reliable, the modern version may be superior. I have never seen a P series SIG exhibit a problem with the extractor, and the design of the modern Scorpion is good.

The trigger isn’t a concave or curved design; it is the flat trigger first introduced to the author by Hilton Yam of 10 8 Precision. The trigger is responsive to a skilled operator. Trigger compression should be straight to the rear and this trigger is a boon to a skilled user. A skilled user is a handgunner that practices. And that is the bottom line—learning to manage and use the handgun well.

Gun metal gray SIG SAUER Scorpion on a brown/black/gray stone background, barrel pointing upward.
The SIG is at home in the field as on the belt. This is a fine all-around useful packing handgun.

I chose the Commander-length Scorpion for several reasons. The Scorpion is designed for personal defense. While the 5-inch gun is a great service pistol and well suited to home defense or competition, the shorter 4.25-inch barrel handgun is easier to carry and better suited to the demands of personal defense. The .75-inch shorter slide and barrel clear leather more quickly (the balance is ideal for personal defense).

I have the impression that the shorter slide, with less mass, cycles more quickly than a Government Model. It will take an excellent shot with much experience with the 1911 to prove it, but firing tests seem to bear this impression out. The Commander .45 is my fit for personal defense. The Scorpion may be the most advanced example of the type, yet it is still a Commander length.

I believe the pistol is more controllable in some drills than a Government Model simply because of the faster slide velocity. Just the same, the cadence of fire isn’t set by how quickly you are able to pull the trigger; It is set by how quickly you are able to recover from recoil and realign the sights. When mastering the handgun the only thing better than practical experience is a lot of practical experience. The pistol needs to be fired, and fired a lot, in realistic training.

Field Stripping the Scorpion

Light blue SIG SAUER Scorption with focus on medium/dark blue rail on stone background.
The light rail opens several possibilities.

Prior to the initial shooting evaluation, the Scorpion was field stripped for inspection. I used the Perry tool, which makes field stripping more convenient, but the Scorpion is a service grade handgun without a full length guide rail. There is no requirement for special tools to field strip the pistol.

There were no tool marks of any type evident and final fit and polish is good. The pistol features a snug fit between the barrel bushing and the barrel, although it is not difficult to field strip. The pistol is tight, but not so tight that it isn’t easily field stripped and maintained. A caution with this pistol, and any other pistol, using the Series 80 positive firing pin block must be observed when the pistol is field stripped. When returning the slide to the frame during reassembly be certain the plunger for the drop safety is depressed. Otherwise the part could be damaged.

After field stripping and examination, the long bearing surfaces were lubricated. During the evaluation, the pistol was used with the supplied SIG magazines and also a back up set of Wilson Combat ETM magazines. The ETM magazine feeds the bullet nose more directly into the chamber at a higher attitude, resulting in more positive feed. Be sure to take every advantage in reliability.

Shooting Evaluation

Initial firing was accomplished with Winchester’s USA ball ammunition. This ‘White Box’ ammunition is affordable and accurate enough for meaningful practice. Do not be confused by those with little, or no real experience, in the field. The 230-grain ‘Hardball’ is an excellent battle round with good penetration and wound ballistics. A .451-inch projectile is likely to fully penetrate the target, leaving a wound on entering and a predictably larger wound on exiting to create an impressive total wound volume.

The 230-grain load operates at relatively mild pressure, exhibits a full powder burn with a low muzzle signature (usually just a few sparks), and is feed-reliable in any handgun. The 230-grain FMJ bullet delivers good practical accuracy. The Scorpion gets on target quickly, and with attention to the sight picture, sight alignment and trigger press, X ring hits are the rule. The initial evaluation was spent firing at man-sized targets at 7, 10 and 15 yards. Results were good. The front sight simply hangs on the target as a trained shooter delivers.

Switching to the 230-grain JHP in the Winchester Personal Defense line, the pistol’s handling was identical. This load offers excellent expansion and a good balance between expansion and penetration. It is among the under-appreciated loadings available and an excellent performer at a fair price.

However, if you are facing felons behind cover as part of the likely scenario, or have a need to penetrate vehicle glass or intermediate cover, more thought should go into selecting a loading with good penetration. The Winchester 230-grain PDX is the answer. This load exhibited more recoil than the other 230-grain loads, as it is a bit faster. The bonded core bullet stays together during penetration and the load gives formidable performance. These Winchester cartridges never failed to feed, chamber, fire or eject. Practical accuracy in speed shooting is excellent with this handgun.

With a weapon mounted light, the balance of the handgun wasn’t affected. There just isn’t that much weight in a combat light. In some variations of the polymer frame handgun the weapon mounted light affects reliability. The cause is difficult to qualify but polymer frame pistols have a certain give in recoil, and the combat light may affect this dynamic. The steel frame SIG should be free from this problem. The Scorpion is approaching 1,000 rounds without a problem of any type. Several magazines of full-power loads have been fired with the combat light in place without difficulty.

The author gives the Scorpion a clean bill of health, and a rousing endorsement as a service handgun. The SIG is reliable, accurate and appropriate to the task of personal defense and arguably makes the most of the finest fighting handgun design on the planet.

 25-yard Benchrest Group

 

Load Velocity Average of two, 5-shot groups
Winchester 230-gr. FMJ 802 fps 2.5 inches
Winchester 230-gr. JHP PD 850 fps 1.9 inches
Winchester 230-gr. PDX 874 fps 2.25 inches
Wolf Performance Ammunition 230-gr. FMJ 822 fps 3.0 inches
Wolf Performance Ammunition 185-gr. JHP 890 fps 2.4 inches

Handload

Load Velocity Average of two, 5-shot groups
200-gr. Oregon Trail SWC/WW 231 Powder 856 fps 2.2 inches
230-gr. Oregon Trail FP/Titegroup Powder 780 fps 2.8 inches

Are you a 1911 fan? What are your thoughts on the Scorpion? Tell us in the comment section.

[bob]

About the Author:

Bob Campbell

Bob Campbell’s primary qualification is a lifelong love of firearms, writing, and scholarship. He holds a degree in Criminal Justice but is an autodidact in matters important to his readers. Campbell considers unarmed skills the first line of defense and the handgun the last resort. (He gets it honest- his uncle Jerry Campbell is in the Boxer’s Hall of Fame.)

Campbell has authored well over 6,000 articles columns and reviews and fourteen books for major publishers including Gun Digest, Skyhorse and Paladin Press. Campbell served as a peace officer and security professional and has made hundreds of arrests and been injured on the job more than once.

He has written curriculum on the university level, served as a lead missionary, and is desperately in love with Joyce. He is training his grandchildren not to be snowflakes. At an age when many are thinking of retirement, Bob is working a 60-hour week and awaits being taken up in a whirlwind many years in the future.


Published in
Black Belt Magazine
Combat Handguns
Handloader
Rifle Magazine
Handguns
Gun Digest
Gun World
Tactical World
SWAT Magazine
American Gunsmith
Gun Tests Magazine
Women and Guns
The Journal Voice of American Law Enforcement
Police Magazine
Law Enforcement Technology
The Firearms Instructor
Tactical World
Concealed Carry Magazine
Concealed Carry Handguns



Books published

Holsters for Combat and Concealed Carry
The 1911 Automatic Pistol
The Handgun in Personal Defense
The Illustrated Guide to Handgun Skills
The Hunter and the Hunted
The Gun Digest Book of Personal Defense
The Gun Digest Book of the 1911
The Gun Digest Book of the 1911 second edition
Dealing with the Great Ammunition Shortage
Commando Gunsmithing
The Ultimate Book of Gunfighting
Preppers Guide to Rifles
Preppers Guide to Shotguns
The Accurate Handgun
The Mission of Cheaper Than Dirt!'s blog, The Shooter's Log, is to provide information—not opinions—to our customers and the shooting community. We want you, our readers, to be able to make informed decisions. The information provided here does not represent the views of Cheaper Than Dirt!

Comments (10)

  1. i have a P238 extreme .380 and its awesome.
    Small and very accurate. I also use my Kimber Uktra Carry II in .45 ACP for my CCW gun (night sites and Crimson Trace grip laser… Top notch machine!, along with my Glock 26 in 9mm ( simple yet reliable and accurate pistol, no bells or whistles on this one… But it’s fun and cheap to shoot. Ironically cheaper than both the 45 and 380… I get the 45, but the 380 not so much).
    Anyway SIG makes great quality firearms. Kimber is my benchmark pistol manufacturer… They a simply DEAD accurate right out of the box… Something you’d pay a buttload for in a custom gun…

  2. I too enjoy my sig 1911r scorpion. i got the 5″ model and have had no issues yet up to about the 300 round mark. my worry though is that i have only fed a few HP through it.. mostly ball ammo. my feed ramp looked horrible from the factory with obvious horizontal tool marks and 3 distinct nicks in the feed ramp. instead of sending it back to sig and living without a firearm for weeks i decided to take my chances and polish it myself. i ended up with a gleaming feed ramp that will hopefully not void my warranty. lets hope i can feed some god dots with this thing!.

  3. I own several 1911’s. Colt sig. Taurus and kimber A sig tacops with stream light laser is my bedroom gun a sig carry scorpion my farm truck gun and a kimber ultra carry 11 my ccw gun but if I had only one it would be the carry scorpion

  4. I own several 1911`s, one of them being a Sig Sauer Scorpion Carry, and it has approx. 2000 rounds down the barrel with not one malfunction of any kind, I ordered a Scorpion Carry the other day because of the reliability of my Nightmare, the accuracy is on point. The Nightmare of course has a match grade barrel, trigger, and sear set where the Scorpion does not, but I’ve read that the trigger on the Scorpion is also top notch, furthermore I consider Sig Sauer 1911’s far more than a cheap copy of Colt’s version, as I do also own a Gov’t, and commander size Colt version of Ed Brown’s vision, and I love them too, let’s be honest, I love the 1911 period as long as they are well made and reliable, and I’ve always found the Sig’s I’ve owned to be just that. Thank you sir for the informative review and God Bless.

  5. if you like a 1911 buy a colt 1911. all of this baloney about someone else can make one better. all of the 1911s on the market are cheaper than the colt…unless it is a colt masquerading as something else and has been customized. its the same thing with that colt mustang in .380…why buy a kahr…you know the colt is gonna work right out of the box. i have read a lot of articles about kahr pistols…they are not a colt!! also, they are cheaper. now stan has to mess around with his 380 kahr. i bet you by the time he gets it working properly, it will have cost him another armload of money. net result, it is not as good as a colt. they also load differently than a colt and i know that they are a lot more fussy, its easy to mess up a spring inside it when you take the slide off of it to clean it. dont get me wrong…i own a couple of kahrs!!! wish i had just plain spent the money and got a colt 1911 and a colt 380 mustang. unless you fire thousands of rounds through any of these brands you will never realize just how inexspensive the colt really is..cant break it so it doesnt break!!! no gunsmithing involved. no, i dont have any affiliation with colt or anybody else..started shooting a colt 45 during the viet nam era… i will never buy anything but a cole centerfire again. if you disagree with me, post a comment.

    1. Colt fanboys are everywhere, but a Colt is not the benchmark for every gun out there. Colt guns used to be innovative and they are the “originals” for some models, but that does not make them better than other guns. Other companies, such as Sig Sauer, have made fantastic guns that are equal to, if not better than, Colt 1911s. The Sig Scorpion 5″ 1911 is an excellent 1911 and is by far my favorite 1911.

  6. well, the most accurate 1911 i ever shot was a colt, areal colt. it did not have a shortened bbl. it also had about 2000$$ worth of work done on the bushings, slide sights trigger, etc. . but the real point i am making. if you work with a gun, as in a law enforcement military, etc. they are great. for the ordinary personal defense carry all the time in the civilian world…it is one heck of an anchor to be toten around. i would like to see some real hard performance tests done for the glock model 42, .380 cal. and also the kahr pm line up. i own a p.380. i have it in a cheap wallet type holster, you can just put it in your pocket. i am no master of accuracy,however, i will have no problem putting a trespasser down in the middle of the night. i think a gun like this sig has its place but not to carry around every day of your life. maybe im wrong, but that thing looks like an anchor to me…maybe a colt mustang in .380 cal.??? give me some feedback of what i am missing on the positives here. stanlie

  7. Great review. Acurate, complete and well adjusted. Will scope out a Scorpion first visit to gun shop this year!

    Thanks, Wishing You The Best For 2014

  8. Shooting from the left side AND being a fan of 1911’s I LOVE TO SEE A SAFETY FOR US SOUTH PAWS ………………….

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit exceeded. Please click the reload button and complete the captcha once again.

Your discussions, feedback and comments are welcome here as long as they are relevant and insightful. Please be respectful of others. We reserve the right to edit as appropriate, delete profane, harassing, abusive and spam comments or posts, and block repeat offenders. All comments are held for moderation and will appear after approval.