Review of the Ruger LC9: Is it TOO Safe?

By CTD Blogger published on in Firearms, Handguns, Pistols, Reviews, Self Defense

Shiny new LC9 brand new in the boxCaleb Giddings wrote a brief review and discussed the details of Ruger’s compact LC9 9mm pistol when it was first announced in early January 2011. When we received our first shipment of LC9 pistols, we immediately took one out for testing and evaluation.

First, we took the new shooter to the photo studio and opened the box to see what goodies Ruger included with their new pistol. It was a pleasant surprise to see a Ruger-branded soft-sided case was included, along with the user manual and a magazine. A standard cable-padlock is included, as were two keys for the padlock and two more keys with the Ruger emblem on them. Further inspection revealed these two Ruger branded keys fit a child safety lock on the rear of the right side of the pistol. They are also necessary to field strip the pistol, so don’t lose them!

Ruger LC9 Functions

Ruger included a manual frame-mounted thumb safety on the LC9 that blocks the firing pin and locks the slide in place—similar to the safety on a 1911. The trigger pull is a consistent and silky-smooth double-action pull, with no double-strike capability. The slide must be cycled for the action to be charged. This was a bit perplexing since the LC9 is not a striker-fired pistol and instead relies on a mainspring and hammer.

The LC9 has a California-approved loaded chamber indicator which clearly displays unmistakable tactile and visual cues that the pistol has a round chambered. At first glance, it may appear that the chamber indicator might interfere with the front sight; fortunately a quick glance after lining up the white 3-dot sights shows it is low enough to remain out of the way.

The sights are a simple 3-dot setup with a windage-adjustable front and fixed rear sight.

The LC9 is equipped with a magazine disconnect safety that locks the action when the magazine is removed. The design allows the gun to fire if the magazine is at least partially inserted. This prevents the LC9 from being disabled in a firefight if the mag release is inadvertently engaged or the mag is not fully seated. The magazine itself is a single-stack design with a 7-round capacity. It comes from the factory with a finger grip extension installed on the baseplate to give you more positive control. You can easily remove the grip extension to reduce printing when carrying concealed.

In fact, the entire pistol has been designed for concealed carry. Ruger added a slide lock/release lever and a small, easily usable frame-mounted safety, both features requested by customers. With both a thumb safety and double-action trigger, and a total width of just .9-inch, the LC9 is perfect as a pocket-carry gun. The controls are low profile, and the edges have been given a melt treatment and rounded smooth to eliminate snagging when drawing from concealment.

At the Range

On the range, the LC9 performed flawlessly. Recoil was a bit snappy, though manageable, using 115-grain 9mm FMJ BVAC ammunition. Muzzle velocities averaged around 1125 FPS, which is just about right given the LC9′s short 3-inch barrel. The sights on most pistols this size are marginal at best, although the bright 3-dot sight system on the LC9 was instinctive and on target at 7 yards out of the box. Groups measured three to six inches at 7 yards, Given the long, double-action trigger and small sight radius,  this is quite acceptable for little pistol.

Disassembly of the LC9 is tedious to say the least. Field stripping requires the use of the Ruger-provided key. If that is not available a punch, nail or other similar device works. A takedown panel on the left side of the pistol reveals a takedown pin, which must be alined with a notch in the slide and then punched out from the other side using Ruger’s special tool.

After that, disassembly is fairly straightforward. The slide pulls forward off of the frame, and the dual recoil springs and guide rod assembly are easily removed followed by the barrel.

Too Safe?

Some have argued Ruger missed the mark with this gun by its incorporation of a plethora of safety features and controls. The fault, however, lies with the gun’s creators. While Ruger performed the engineering and design needed to put the pistol into production, the features incorporated into the LC9 were drawn from their “Voice of the Customer” program. California and other states with restrictive gun control laws make up a large portion of Ruger’s customer base, and the inclusion of a large chamber indicator and child-safety lock ensured the LC9 met the legal guidelines for those states.

Ruger CEO Michael Fifer commented on the genesis of the LC9 saying, “On the heels of the overwhelming and ongoing success of the LCP, customers repeatedly requested a lightweight, compact 9mm pistol. Frankly, they wanted an LCP chambered in 9mm. Delivering an American-made, compact 9mm that provides the same legendary Ruger reliability as the award-winning LCP, LCR and SR9 became our focus. Meeting customer expectations is our goal and key to Ruger’s continuing success.”

While some may dislike features such as the magazine disconnect and chamber-loaded indicator, Ruger clearly listened to customer requests. The overwhelming majority requested features that ensures the pistol is available and legal in nearly any local jurisdiction. With the typical attention to performance and reliability, Ruger has developed yet another fantastic pistol that is sure to appeal to anyone seeking an easily concealed 9mm defensive handgun.

Ruger LC9 Specifications:

Overall length: 6 inches
Barrel length: 3.12 inches
Width: 0.90-inch
Height: 4.50 inches
Weight: 17.10 ounces
Capacity: 7+1 rounds
Rifling: 6 groove, 1:10 right hand twist
Finish: Blued
MSRP: $443.00

Click here to purchase a Ruger LC9

Check out a selection of holsters that fit the Ruger LC9

Have you taken the Ruger LC9 for a spin? What did you like? Not like? Share your opinion in the comment section.

 

Tags: , , , , ,

Trackback from your site.

The mission of Cheaper Than Dirt!'s blog, "The Shooter's Log," is to provide information-not opinions-to our customers and the shooting community. We want you, our readers, to be able to make informed decisions. The information provided here does not represent the views of Cheaper Than Dirt!

Comments (136)

  • clamboslice

    |

    The thing is absurd, lousy ergonomics, lousy trigger, huge recoil, can’t hit a barn door, etc.
    A guy above said he got a tiny group from this trash at 25 yards? Maybe clamped to a vise with a string to pull the trigger.
    Why is this post negative? I am afraid some new gun buyer will google the gun and read glowing reviews.
    This is a lousy popgun the only thing it does is go bang, that’s not enough for me to buy anything.
    I suppose it’s an effective weapon from a couple of yards, but why buy junk?

    Reply

  • Mike H

    |

    For those that Hate Safeties on Conceal Handguns such as the Ruger Models…..
    Just Don’t flip the safety on
    I have an SRc9 and Bought it based on plenty of Safety built into the weapon.
    That does not mean i have to use the safeties……so the option is there for anyones needs or preferences. I bought the SRc9 because it comes with a 17 round magazine and great safety features.

    Reply

  • Ric

    |

    Mike, I don’t really think the safety itself is an issue…Ruger generally puts out a great product, but I think the LC9 needs some revamping… I’ve had one for quite some time now and I’ve switched over to a different weapon for two reasons…

    1) The LC9 has the most horrible trigger pull I’ve ever seen in a gun and I shouldn’t have to buy a kit to fix the problem

    2) The extended mag needs to be seated better…. when practicing combat reloads I pinched my finger way to often to make the LC9 a viable off duty carry weapon.

    My original comments on this gun were favorable, however, over time and much use, the LC9 doesn’t suit my needs.

    Reply

  • Luke

    |

    The magazine safety seems foolish for a carry gun…

    Lets just say that you are attacked… and.. in the tussle the magazine release is accidentally depressed and the magazine drops free from the gun.. Now you have a loaded gun with 1 round the chamber and IT WILL NOT SHOOT….!!

    Sorry, not for me…. I would buy one if it were not for this shortcoming…

    Reply

  • Russ

    |

    Love my LCP. Hate the LC9 for all the extra crap they added to it. Won’t buy it unless they redesign it like the LCP. That’s my voice. And my wallet. In lockstep! ;-)

    Reply

  • Bill Thedford

    |

    All of the overly safe features of this excellent double action concealed weapon are very easily disabled and the only real drawback for me was the one inch trigger pull and two pound stack which are easily overcome with an aftermarket hammer bar and spring to shorten the pull combined with an aftermarket 20 pound recoil spring and a really good polishing of the hammer bar safety removes all stack for an extremely smooth 3/4 inch no stack trigger I kept the thumb safety on mine a little range time and firing both left and right handed you get used to it I replaced the loaded chamber indicator with a polished modified indicator seems to me there would be a market for fluff and buff modifications pack for this weapon

    Reply

Leave a comment

Your discussions, feedback and comments are welcome here as long as they are relevant and insightful. Please be respectful of others. We reserve the right to edit as appropriate, delete profane, harassing, abusive and spam comments or posts, and block repeat offenders. All comments are held for moderation and will appear after approval.


7 − = three