NRA: No Second-Guessing the Second Amendment

By CTD Blogger published on in General

In 1776, America’s Founders came together in Philadelphia to draw up a “Declaration of Independence,” ending political ties to Great Britain. Written by Thomas Jefferson, the Declaration explains people’s rights and how people create governments:

WE hold these Truths to be self-evident, that all Men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness-That to secure these Rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just Powers from the Consent of the Governed.

By Robert Pew

In modern English: We don’t get our rights from the government; we’re born with those rights, and the government should protect them.

Eleven years later, after independence had been won, our Founders assembled once again to draw up a plan for governing the new nation. That plan became the Constitution of the United States of America.

Constitution of the United States

During the debate over the Constitution, many Americans were worried that a strong federal government would trample on the individual rights of citizens, as the British had done. To protect the basic rights of Americans, the Founders added the first 10 amendments to the Constitution. Those amendments are known as the Bill of Rights. They represent the fundamental freedoms that are at the heart of our society, including the First Amendment freedoms of speech and religion, and the Second Amendment right of the people to keep and bear arms.

The meaning of the Second Amendment has been debated for decades. Does the Second Amendment protect an individual right for all Americans? Or does it only protect the right to keep and bear arms while participating in an organized force, such as the National Guard? Or does it only protect the “right” of the states to have a National Guard in the first place?

Some people have claimed there was no individual right to keep and bear arms. However, anyone who understands the Declaration of Independence knows that rights-by definition-belong to individuals. And in the Bill of Rights, the freedoms of religion, freedom of speech and the rest all refer to individual liberties.

The Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms is no different. The first Congress had no doubt about its meaning. Most of the Founders were gun owners and hunters. George Washington and Thomas Jefferson exchanged letters about their gun collections. The Founders had just finished winning their freedoms with guns in their hands, and soon passed a law requiring most male citizens to own at least one gun and 30 rounds of ammunition. They believed citizens should be able to protect themselves and their country against attacks on life and liberty.

So, where did anyone get the idea that the Second Amendment doesn’t protect an individual right? That theory was invented in the 20th century, by people who rejected what seemed like common sense to our Founding Fathers. Instead, they claimed that the Second Amendment only protects the government.

Now, the Supreme Court has thrown out that idea.

In 1975, Washington, D.C. passed some of the most extreme gun laws in the nation. Handguns were banned. All guns had to be stored disassembled and locked, making them useless for self-defense. City leaders claimed it would make the city safer. But Washington’s murder rate soared, and our nation’s capital soon became known as America’s murder capital.

In 2003, a group of Washington residents filed a lawsuit challenging these harsh gun laws. They said that Washington’s gun laws violated the Second Amendment because the laws took away the right to use firearms for self-defense, even in their own homes.

The first court that heard the case said that D.C.’s laws were constitutional. The residents appealed, and the appeals court agreed that the laws violated the right to keep and bear arms, after all.

Now, the city appealed. By 2008, the case, which by then was known as D.C. vs. Heller, had gone to the Supreme Court. To make their decision, the Supreme Court justices studied the words and history of the Second Amendment. In a 5-4 decision, the Supreme Court agreed with the citizens: The Second Amendment protects an individual right, not a “state’s right.” The decision struck down the District’s laws that banned handguns and that kept people from using guns for self-defense in their homes.

No Supreme Court decision ever ends a political debate, though. Now, the NRA and citizens around the country are going to court to challenge states and cities with restrictive gun laws. But the landmark Heller decision provided a key answer to the most important part of the debate: The Second Amendment protects an individual right to keep and bear arms.

Tags: ,

Trackback from your site.

The mission of Cheaper Than Dirt!'s blog, "The Shooter's Log," is to provide information-not opinions-to our customers and the shooting community. We want you, our readers, to be able to make informed decisions. The information provided here does not represent the views of Cheaper Than Dirt!

Comments (27)

  • JB


    The, 2 Amendment, is the “PRIMARY” Amendment to the, “BILL OF RIGHTS and the Constitution”….. Without this critical Amendment, all the others are just written lines on a piece of paper. It is this Amendment that requires and provides every American with the ability to “Support and Defend the Constitution of the United States Against All Enemies, Foreign or Domestic.” “Foreign enemies” are easily identified. It’s the “Domestic” ones that are the hardest to identify and combat against. These people use the Constitution, the Bill of Rights, and the Supreme Court to deprive other Americans of their Civil Rights and to force their beliefs and ideals on them. When these people are allowed to modify, purposely misinterpret, and/or just totally ignore the Rights spelled out in the Constitution and Bill of Rights, it want be long before all your RIGHTS are gone…… Once these Rights are gone, the only way to get them back,is another revolution.


  • Marty


    So you think it is incompetence? I say it is agenda.
    Consider this:
    Does the First Amendment protect an individual right for all Americans? Or does it only protect the right to free speech while participating in an organized force, such as Planned Parenthood or Boy Scouts? Or does it only protect the “right” of the states to have a approved groups speak approvingly in the first place?
    This sounds silly. I merely exchanged the 2nd amendment terms with 1st amendment terms.
    The fact that SCOTUS almost always splits 4 conservative 3 liberal means aganda drives decisions.


  • slt


    Just think of how scary it is that the decision was 5-4.


  • RPK


    WE THE PEOPLE elect those who govern us and in the same respect, WE RETAIN THE RIGHT to remove such persons through impeachment or the ballot. WE ARE “the powers that be”. The American citizen. Life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness are GUARANTEED ladies and gentlemen of this forum. I, as an American citizen, ensure these three through RESPONSIBLE firearms ownership and PARTICIPATION in the voting process, as well as membership in like-minded organizations such as the National Rifle Association and Texas State Rifle Association who keep an eye on politicians who seek to pervert our Constitution and Bill of Rights for their own agendas. If we fail to monitor those we have elected, we will no longer continue as a republic. I thank each of you for your opinion as you have shown through participation you cherish your rights too, to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. God Bless America and God Bless Texas!


    • G-Man




    • art


      very true and if all else fails through force. that is also why it was written. an unalienable right is a right that can not be given or taken away. it appears to me that we have already exceeded the control we have given the government and they appear to want to control us. government needs to be reduced. for instance they war on what ever strikes their fancy. take drugs another war that will never be won and should have never started. it is no ones business what i do until i am hurting someone else. my life and my decisions not my uncle sam’s.controlling me is not freedom and has caused more crime and accomplished nothing.


  • MarkRB


    We’ve been brainwashed into believing that only people in robes and politicians have the ability to “interpret” the Constitution. Our Founding Fathers wrote it so that the average citizen can understand it.
    It’s up to us to let our Government know that we will not allow them to pervert the Constitution.


  • Roc


    ‘1. read Thomas Paine’s ‘Common Sense’ [Jan 1776] and its affect on the 2nd Continental Congress [we were at war with GB since Apr 1775 but still considered ourselves British]
    2. Jun, 1776 the 2CC selected a committee including Ben Franklin, John Adams and young whippersnapper named Thomas Jefferson [33 at the time]
    3. the task to write the Declaration of Independence fell upon Jefferson…he ‘borrowed’ concepts from John Locke, Jean Rousseau and Baron de Montesque about a new radical concept called the Social Contract i[also elaborated upon in ‘Common Sense’]…ultimate authority for government comes from the people [individuals not the state] and the people give up some of their individual rights to the government in exchange for the absolute protection of individual Life, Liberty and Property [Locke’s words] or Pursuit of Happiness [Jefferson’s words]
    4. The Declaration of Independence IS the Social Contract; and the government violated the contract repeatedly [para 2] and therefore had no authority to govern the People [read it, don’t assume you know it]
    5. when the Constitution was written some 12 years later [the Ultimate law not ordinary law] and ratified by 3/4’s of the State governments [closest to the people] an immediate argument began by the Anti-Federalists. They could not believe that there was no Bill of Rights….rights that protect the people, the individual, from an abusive central government.
    6. the Federalists countered with the Federalist Papers [read them]
    7. James Madison [the Father of the Constitution] finally agreed the first order of business by the 1st Congress of the US was to write the Bill of Rights, the 1st ten amendments to the Constitution, which guaranteed the rights of the people protected from a potentially tyrannical government…our Social Contract…the 2nd Amendment IS and individual right.

    Read…case closed…revisionist history is a fable

    Also, every officer of the United States and the of the 50 states take an oath to the Constitution…everyone who took this oath [all executive [police], legislative and judicial officers] are bound by this sacred oath to the people that they serve…’to support and defend the Constitution of the United States…’

    Infringement of these rights is a clear violation of the oath to the people whom the government serve and protect.


  • Jerry


    I should also being pointed out, that the 2nd Amendment has no “qualifiers” or “exceptions” written into it, as to who can or cannot “keep and bear Arms”.

    And because the 2nd is part of the Constitution, it is the “supreme Law of the Land”. – Article VI, paragraph 2


Leave a comment

Your discussions, feedback and comments are welcome here as long as they are relevant and insightful. Please be respectful of others. We reserve the right to edit as appropriate, delete profane, harassing, abusive and spam comments or posts, and block repeat offenders. All comments are held for moderation and will appear after approval.

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload the CAPTCHA.

%d bloggers like this: