I have tested quite a few shotguns during the past few months. Many of them have been pump-action shotguns. This pump-action clone of the Winchester 1897 is my hands down favorite for fun shooting. While affordable, it is of good quality, reliable, and offers a period look that cannot be beat.
The ’97 Wild Bunch gun has become a favorite recreational shooter. After firing some 250 mixed shells in this shotgun over the past few weeks, I have found it reliable enough for personal defense. I would rather have it than some of the more modern appearing economy grade shotguns. It is that good! Let’s look first at the great, great granddaddy of them all.
The Winchester 1897 shotgun was manufactured from 1897 to 1957. At one time, the ’97 set the standard for combat shotguns. With a five-round tubular magazine, fed by a helical coil spring and featuring a reliable slide action, the ’97 is a rugged serviceable shotgun. The exposed hammer is the trademark of the ’97.
This shotgun was used with great effect during the Philippine war against the Moros and emerged with a solid reputation. During World War I, a special version with heat shield and bayonet lug was known as the Trench Gun. This was a particularly famous version of the ’97 noted for deadly efficiency.
I own an original; a 1957 model that has been cut down into a riot gun. The modern clone gun is popular in Cowboy Shooting. This is primarily, because they are correct for the new Wild Bunch side matches.
Wishing to evaluate this modern clone, I first tried to obtain the Trench Gun version but that soon proved too difficult. I settled for the plain, short-barrel version with no heat shield or bayonet lug. I do not think I missed much. Fit and finish are much better than expected. The wood is well turned out and attractive.
The Wild Bunch shotgun operates in an identical manner to the original. The truth be told, it is smoother than the original. I have fired this replica of the ’97 a great deal. It looks right, and it is fun to fire.
The simple bread front sight usually results in the load being centered about four inches high on the target. The action is smooth enough, and the exposed hammer offers a degree of safety in handling. I do not recommend keeping the chamber loaded for home defense; rack the slide and load the chamber when ready to fire.
I began the test firing a good quantity of Winchester No. 7 ½ birdshot. I found the shotgun smooth in operation. The pump action is a bit longer than most modern actions but very fast. Switching to Fiocchi No. 4 Turkey loads, recoil was stronger but not difficult to control.
I also fired a representative example of the Fiocchi reduced-recoil 12 gauge buckshot loads. These are ideal practice loads and viable for personal protection. A trick inherent in the design of the ’97 is that the trigger may be held down and the hammer will fall as the action is cycled. While I fail to see the tactical advantage of this system I have never faced a charging Moro.
Most shooters attempting a run with the ’97—in this firing mode—hit significantly low as they over compensated for recoil. It is preferable to control firing with the trigger rather than the slide. Just the same, with a bit of practice, this firing mode might be a lifesaver. At any rate, it is fun to try occasionally.
The shotgun appears to be disassembling itself as the action is worked. The shell carrier actually protrudes from the lower receiver. The shotgun has some advantages over modern designs other than the lack of a disconnect.
The large ejection port is open more on the top than simply just the side. This makes quickly loading the chamber easier than with the modern pump-action shotgun. The shotgun has proven easily handled, and while different, the balance is good.
While only time will tell as to longevity, at present these shotguns are giving plenty of bang! for the buck. Wild Bunch shotguns have been around for a few years in America, and after seeing some use in SASS shoots, they seem to be holding up well. I am no stranger to pump-action shotguns. I have compared the ’97 clone to the Remington 870 and even the Benelli Nova Tactical.
The Benelli has a large ejection port and ghost rings sight; it is quite a versatile shotgun. But there was little I could do with the Benelli I could not do with the ’97 at 10 to 15 yards. During the test, I used the Winchester PDX to evaluate the shotguns recoil—after all, it doesn’t have a butt pad. Recoil was never uncomfortable. This loading uses three buckshot balls over a one ounce slug. The slug offers plenty of knockdown power, the buckshot offers hit probability. I like this load a great deal.
When all is said and done, the Wild Bunch clone gun is a great choice for many uses. It is well suited to Cowboy Action shooting, and it will defend the homestead as well. Pride of ownership is there, and this piece is a lot of fun. The ’97 Wild Bunch is a great buy as well.
Pietta 1873 SAA
More on the Wild Bunch—since it was a retro kind of day, I also worked out the Pietta 1873 SAA in .45 Colt. I enjoy packing and firing this revolver very much and often carry it when hiking. It just feels right and it is brilliantly fast into action. While accurate and well made and well suited for Wild Bunch Competition, the Pietta is one of my favorite outdoors revolvers. I like the 4 ¾-inch barrel length for general use. The Fiocchi 250-grain Cowboy load will group three shots into less than two inches at 15 yards. For town carry, the Winchester 225-grain PDX JHP is a serious defense load. The .45 Colt is a respectable cartridge that offers excellent ballistics without heavy recoil. Sometimes, the cowboy way makes a lot of sense.
Are you a fan of the ’97? How does the Wild Bunch rank among your favorite shotguns? Share your answers in the comment section.
Bob Campbell is a former peace officer and published author with over 40 years combined shooting and police and security experience. Bob holds a degree in Criminal Justice. Bob is the author of the books, The Handgun in Personal Defense, Holsters for Combat and Concealed Carry, The 1911 Automatic Pistol, The Gun Digest Book of Personal Protection and Home Defense, The Shooters Guide to the 1911, The Hunter and the Hunted, and The Complete Illustrated Manual of Handgun Skills. His latest book is Dealing with the Great Ammo Shortage. He is also a regular contributor to Gun Tests, American Gunsmith, Small Arms Review, Gun Digest, Concealed Carry Magazine, Knife World, Women and Guns, Handloader and other publications. Bob is well-known for his firearm testing.
Trackback from your site.